Repository navigation
Update Hawaii deductions for Act 35 conformity - #9940
Conversation
hi_itemized_deductions picked the reduced amount using the federal 2009 personal exemption phase-out thresholds (250,200 joint, 208,500 head of household, 125,100 separate) instead of Hawaii's 166,800 / 83,400, and returned 0 when medical, investment interest and casualty deductions made up the whole total. Replace hi_reduced_itemized_deductions with hi_itemized_deductions_reduction (worksheet lines 2-10) on Hawaii-owned parameters for the 3% and 80% rates and the excluded deductions. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ions Act 35, SLH 2026 conforms Hawaii to the Internal Revenue Code as of December 31, 2025 without making section 224 (qualified tips) or 170(p) (charitable deduction for non-itemizers) inoperative. Add hi_tip_income_deduction for 2026-2028, phased out on Hawaii AGI and denied to separate filers (224(f)), and give Hawaii non-itemizers the federal 170(p) amount on top of the standard deduction (also restores the 2020 Act 13 and 2021 Act 89 amounts). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
… for charitable limits Hawaii kept the 2% miscellaneous itemized deductions for 2018-2025 (it never adopted the section 67(g) suspension); Act 35, SLH 2026 ends them from 2026. Add hi_misc_deduction gated by a Hawaii parameter. The N-11 instructions state the section 170(b) limits as a share of Hawaii AGI, and Act 35 conforms to the 0.5% floor from 2026. Move the federal charitable_deduction formula into a helper that takes the contribution base, unchanged for the federal deduction, and add hi_charitable_deduction on Hawaii AGI. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…s deduction Checks the reduction against an independent restatement of the Total Itemized Deductions Worksheet, its bounds, monotonicity, identical 2025 and 2026 results under Act 35, and the tips deduction's bounds and years. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
PR Review: Update Hawaii income tax for Act 35 (2025 IRC conformity) and fix its itemized deduction limitSummaryThe core of this PR is right, and I checked it against the law first. Act 35, SLH 2026 (H.B. 2329 C.D. 1, effective May 26, 2026, for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2025) does the following:
DOTAX Announcement 2026-06 (PDF pp. 2-3) confirms each of those points. It adds that Hawaii conforms to 67(h), to the section 170 non-itemizer deduction and floor, and to section 224. The Pease fix matches the 2021 and 2025 N-11 Total Itemized Deductions Worksheets line for line: $166,800 ($83,400 separate) for every filing status, the 80%/3% rates, Hawaii AGI, and line 4's "not limited" case. The 2021-2025 miscellaneous deduction and the 2026 non-itemizer charity are also right. On main, joint, head-of-household and surviving-spouse filers between $166,800 and the 2009 personal-exemption thresholds were never limited, and medical-only itemizers got $0. Both bugs are real, and the PR fixes them. Two of the new Hawaii variables reuse the branch's October 6 copy of a federal formula, and that copy contradicts the statute in claimed years. Main has since fixed both formulas federally (#10192, #10393, #10396). The branch is 765 commits behind main:
Critical (must fix)C1. The variable copies the merge-base federal formula with Hawaii AGI swapped in. That copy has two errors against 26 U.S.C. 224, which Hawaii adopts from 2026:
This is also the "reinvented variable" pattern: the Hawaii copy has already drifted from the federal one it duplicates. Fix:
C2. 26 U.S.C. 170(b)(1)(I), as amended by P.L. 119-21, reads: "Any charitable contribution otherwise allowable (without regard to this subparagraph) as a deduction under this section shall be allowed only to the extent that the aggregate of such contributions exceeds 0.5 percent of the taxpayer's contribution base." Contributions above a ceiling are not "otherwise allowable" this year; they carry over. So the floor comes after the ceilings. The helper (the merge-base federal formula moved unchanged) subtracts the floor and then caps. Two examples:
This bites the households the PR is aimed at. A retiree whose pensions and Social Security leave Hawaii AGI small is the one most likely to hit the 50%/60% ceiling. After a merge the helper is also stale. #10192 rewrote
No test would fail. So the body's point that "the federal and Hawaii deductions cannot drift apart" holds only if the helper is rebuilt on main's function. Fix:
Should addressS1. The property test fails on a tree merged with main ( Since #10274 (merged 2026-10-23),
This is a merge blocker that the October 7 CI could not see. Fix: use S2. The axiom line doesn't cover this PR's changes The line cites TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#1521. That issue is OPEN, labelled The extension for this PR's provisions was never posted. Issue #1521 has one comment, about NY medical expenses. Those provisions are:
So no open, dispatch-ready issue matches the head. The line also cites a local file and an internal decision id, which don't belong in a public PR body. Fix:
S3. References split one PDF into several entries (CLAUDE.md: "One
Fix:
Sibling #10200 already uses the correct form for the same 2025 N-11 pages. Suggestions
Verified correct
Hand checks (head formulas):
Axiom line assessmentThe line is not valid for this head (S2). #1521 is OPEN,
Related open issues (#1663 for wagering losses in the same worksheet, #1556 for mortgage limits) don't cover them either. CI status35/35 checks pass, all completed by 2026-10-07. That run predates main's source-conflict ratchet (#10287), #9558, #10317, #10408, #10186, #10192, #10274 and the federal tips fixes, so a fresh run after merging main is needed. Branch status
Verdict: REQUEST_CHANGES |
DTrim99
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Requesting changes: 2 critical ((1) hi_tip_income_deduction copies the old federal formula, with a continuous phase-out instead of § 224(b)(2)'s $100 per full $1,000, and it counts dependents' tips; rebuild on main's federal pieces; (2) hi_charitable_deduction applies the 2026 0.5% floor before the ceilings, while § 170(b)(1)(I) applies it to contributions otherwise allowable: Case 5 should be 49,500, not 50,000), 3 should (the property test fails on the merged tree since #10274; the axiom line's #1521 covers only casualty losses, and it cites a local path; split PDF references). 765 behind main with 5 conflicts. Full report in the comment above.
Use shared federal calculations for qualified tips and charitable donations. Preserve Hawaii's dependent deduction limit and pool miscellaneous expenses with repayments under one floor. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
David, here's where each item of your review stands at
The merge resolves the five conflicts you listed, and the branch still merges cleanly with main. An independent AI review approved 🤖 Generated with Claude Code |
Commit 430d72b merges main and answers each item of this review. My reply above maps each item to its file and line.
|
US + core hub merge audit, us#9940 at
🤖 Generated with Claude Code |
Both sides split the federal charitable deduction formula. Keep charitable_deduction_given_contribution_base from #9940, which Hawaii calls with its own adjusted gross income, and split the ceilings out of it as charitable_deduction_before_floor_given_contribution_base, which charitable_deduction_before_floor now calls with federal positive AGI. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
#9940 on main replaced hi_reduced_itemized_deductions with hi_itemized_deductions_reduction and a list of the deductions Hawaii's limitation leaves out. Take main's deletion and add wagering_losses_deduction to that list: filers enter gambling losses on line 2d of the Total Itemized Deductions Worksheet. Move this branch's Hawaii cases to main's test files with the same expected deductions. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Summary
Update Hawaii deductions for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2025, under Act 35, SLH 2026 and DOTAX Announcement 2026-06. The limitation, the miscellaneous deduction, the Hawaii-AGI charitable limits and the 2021 non-itemizer amount also change results for years before 2026.
Hawaii retains the section 68 itemized deduction limitation with the 2009 thresholds. Apply $166,800 to every filing status except married filing separately, which uses $83,400, and retain protected deductions when they comprise the whole total. Subtract the smaller of 3% of Hawaii AGI above the threshold and 80% of nonprotected deductions. See the 2025 N-11 worksheet, page 34.
Allow qualified tips from 2026 through 2028, using the federal eligibility and calculation with Hawaii AGI. Exclude dependents' tips and tips received by a filer without an eligible SSN. Reduce the deduction by $100 per complete $1,000 of excess AGI, following Schedule 1-A, lines 11-13.
Add the federal nonitemizer charitable amount to the applicable Hawaii standard deduction, then add the tips deduction for itemizers and nonitemizers. Preserve the dependent-filer standard deduction limit. The 2020 charitable adjustment continues through federal AGI without a second deduction below the line.
Allow miscellaneous expenses through 2025 using main's existing Hawaii conformity parameter. Pool those expenses with miscellaneous claim-of-right repayments before applying the 2% Hawaii-AGI floor, while keeping section 1341 repayments outside that pool.
Compute charitable deductions using Hawaii AGI, the federal donation categories and the shared federal calculation. Apply the category ceilings before the 0.5% floor from 2026, as Congress requires for otherwise allowable contributions in P.L. 119-21, section 70425.
Invariants
Methodology choices
Use Hawaii AGI for the tips phase-out. HRS 235-1 defines AGI through the IRC with Hawaii modifications, and DOTAX uses Hawaii AGI for comparable deduction limits. This remains an inference pending a Hawaii tips worksheet.
Hawaii makes sections 911, 931 and 933 inoperative (signed Act 35, PDF page 11), so Hawaii AGI by law includes the income those sections exclude federally. PolicyEngine's
hi_agistarts from federal AGI and doesn't yet add that income, so a filer with such income phases out on a base that omits it. For example, take a single filer with $140,000 of wages, $10,000 of them tips, and $30,000 of section 911 income. The model deducts $10,000, where Hawaii AGI of $170,000 gives $8,000. The gap predates this PR and reaches every rule that reads Hawaii AGI.Use Hawaii AGI for charitable ceilings and the floor, following the contribution-base treatment in the 2025 N-11 instructions, pages 17-18. Reuse federal contribution categories and current-year deduction calculations; this change adds no carryover tracking.
The 2026 N-11 instructions URLs still returned 404 on November 13, 2026.
Validation
The seven touched YAML files hold 90 cases, and
test_hi_itemized_deduction_limitation_properties.pyadds five property tests. The cases cover both sides of the first two $1,000 tips steps, a tipped dependent, a spouse without an eligible SSN and each charitable ceiling ahead of the floor. They also cover the pooled 2% floor, each filing status above its limitation threshold, and a dependent filer's standard deduction.Pull request run 43611581007 at
430d72b440passed all 36 jobs on GitHub's merge with main9a63ae6605.Microsimulation impact
We estimate that this branch lowers
hi_income_taxby $4.5m in 2026 on the default dataset, for 144 sampled tax units (80,037 weighted). We comparedmainat3386304d28with this branch at430d72b440.hi_income_taxhi_itemized_deductionshi_taxable_incomestate_income_taxincome_taxhousehold_benefitshousehold_net_incomeMain doesn't define
hi_tip_income_deduction, so the table leaves it out.axiom: TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2219 queued (qualified tips, non-itemizer gifts, the Hawaii-AGI charitable base and floor, and miscellaneous deductions through 2025); TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#1663 queued, extended with a comment on the limitation worksheet; TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#1796 queued for the repayments that share the 2% floor; the pinned corpus lacks Act 35, DOTAX Announcement 2026-06 and the N-11 itemized worksheets, so the signed encoder can't run yet
🤖 Generated with Claude Code