Skip to content

Apply Minnesota's charitable floor and property tax cap - #10872

Merged
MaxGhenis merged 12 commits into
mainfrom
mn-charitable-floor-property-tax-cap
Nov 17, 2026
Merged

MaxGhenis merged 12 commits into
mainfrom
mn-charitable-floor-property-tax-cap

Conversation

@MaxGhenis

@MaxGhenis MaxGhenis commented Nov 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Minnesota filers apply the state's 1% charitable floor from 2026 when they itemize or claim the non-itemizer subtraction. The Legislature set the floor in Laws 2026, chapter 128, article 1, section 4, amending section 290.0122, subdivision 4. Non-itemizers apply that floor before they subtract half of the amount over $500 under section 290.0132, subdivision 7.

The Minnesota Legislature has capped the deduction for combined real estate and personal property taxes at $10,000, or $5,000 for a married person filing separately, since tax year 2019, under section 290.0122, subdivision 3(a)(1). PolicyEngine previously capped real estate taxes alone at the federal SALT limit, which rose to $40,000 in 2025.

For example, a filer with $100,000 of adjusted gross income and $4,000 of gifts in 2026 deducts $3,500 federally when itemizing and $3,000 in Minnesota. A non-itemizer with the same income and gifts subtracts ($3,000 - $500) / 2 = $1,250. In 2025, a homeowner who pays $18,000 of real estate taxes and $12,000 of mortgage interest itemizes $10,000 + $12,000 = $22,000 in Minnesota, before Minnesota's reduction for high incomes. In 2024, a homeowner who pays $7,000 of real estate taxes, $4,000 of personal property taxes and $12,000 of mortgage interest itemizes min($11,000, $10,000) + $12,000 = $22,000, up from $19,000.

Closes #10799
Closes #10800

Invariants

Households outside Minnesota keep main's results, and the federal charitable deduction keeps main's amounts.

For every filing status, in every year from 2019, a Minnesota filer's property tax deduction:

  • lies between zero and the lesser of the taxes paid and the cap ($10,000, or $5,000 for a married person filing separately);
  • stays the same when the real estate and personal property amounts swap;
  • never falls when either tax rises;
  • raises itemized deductions dollar for dollar below the reduction thresholds.

For charitable contributions:

  • The Minnesota amount lies between zero and the federal amount before any floor, and never falls when gifts rise.
  • Before 2026, the Minnesota amount equals the federal deduction. From 2026, a filer deducts gifts in Minnesota only when they exceed 1% of income, and the Minnesota amount trails the federal one by at most 0.5% of income.
  • Before 2026, the federal deduction equals the amount before any floor. From 2026, it equals that amount less 0.5% of income, and never falls below zero. This holds for gifts over a percentage ceiling too.
  • Gifts raise itemized deductions by the Minnesota amount, and lower an itemizer's alternative minimum taxable income by the federal amount.
  • An itemizer takes no charity subtraction. A non-itemizer takes one only when the Minnesota amount exceeds $500.

policyengine_us/tests/core/test_mn_deduction_invariants.py checks each listed invariant on a grid of filing statuses, incomes, taxes and gifts: 80 tax units in each of 2019, 2024 and 2026 for property taxes, and 140 in each of 2025 and 2026 for gifts. Its caps, floors and years come from the statutes.

Federal charitable_deduction.yaml (34 cases) and hi_charitable_deduction.yaml (10) pin the federal and Hawaii amounts, and the new Minnesota variables apply only to Minnesota households.

YAML cases pin the property tax deduction one dollar under, at and one dollar over each cap, and give every filing status a case over its cap. For gifts, they pin the amounts one dollar under, at and one dollar over Minnesota's floor and the $500 subtraction threshold, and for gifts between the federal and Minnesota floors.

The zero-floor reform test sets Minnesota's floor to zero, which allows a Minnesota charitable amount above the federal one.

Methodology choices

  • Keep the federal section 170 deduction in Minnesota AMT under section 290.091, subdivision 2(a)(2)(i). The department instead directs filers to Minnesota's amount on line 11 of its draft 2026 Schedule M1MT. source_conflicts/candidates.yaml records the conflict as us-mn:amt-charitable-contribution-floor, with captures of both statutes, both draft schedules and section 70425 of Public Law 119-21. The conflict ends if the department takes the federal amount on line 11 of its final schedule. We add the register marker after the shared register pins the merged code, as the source-conflict steps require.
  • Start the property tax cap in 2019. The Legislature enacted section 290.0122 for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2018 (Laws 2019, First Special Session, chapter 6, article 1, section 16). Before 2019, mn_property_tax_deduction returns capped_property_taxes, the amount main deducts.
  • Add mn_personal_property_taxes as a Minnesota-only person input, because the model has no general personal property tax input. It defaults to zero, and the deduction sums payments across tax-unit members.
  • From 2026, compute the Minnesota charitable amount from charitable_deduction_before_floor, the federal amount after the percentage ceilings and before the floor. A caller who supplies only charitable_deduction gets no Minnesota charitable deduction from 2026, so supply donations or charitable_deduction_before_floor. Before 2026, both Minnesota uses keep a supplied charitable_deduction.
  • Use the existing positive_agi as the contribution base for Minnesota's floor.
  • Split the federal ceilings into charitable_deduction_before_floor_given_contribution_base. charitable_deduction_given_contribution_base calls it and then applies the federal floor, so Hawaii's deduction and the federal one keep main's steps.
  • Use mn_property_tax_deduction and the Minnesota charitable amount in the HF1938 repeal reform's itemized deductions, as the baseline does. The Legislature amended only subdivision 2 of section 290.0122 in House File 1938 (Laws 2023, chapter 64).
  • Cover current-year gifts only. The model has no charitable carryovers, which the department adds after the floor on its draft 2026 Schedule M1SA. It also has no input for qualified charitable distributions, which section 290.0122, subdivision 4(a), and section 290.0132, subdivision 7, keep out of both amounts.
  • Keep the existing itemization choice, which compares itemized deductions with the standard deduction before the non-itemizer charity subtraction. A filer the model has itemize could owe less with the standard deduction and the subtraction.

Validation

Pull request run 44011545147 at d3bb251c32 passed all 37 jobs on GitHub's merge with main 5b18694981.

  • YAML, all passing: mn_property_tax_deduction.yaml 18, mn_itemized_deductions.yaml 29, mn_charitable_deduction.yaml 11, mn_amt_taxable_income.yaml 10 and mn_charity_subtraction.yaml 2. The federal charitable_deduction.yaml passes 34, hi_charitable_deduction.yaml 10, the reform file reform/mn_charitable_deduction.yaml 1 and the HF1938 file mn_walz_hf1938.yaml 8.
  • Python: test_mn_deduction_invariants.py 5 passed, test_ca_mn_itemized_limitation_properties.py 2 passed and test_source_conflicts.py 251 passed. Ruff format and lint pass, and git diff --check reports nothing.
  • From 2018 through 2024, the model still gives a single filer with $18,000 of real estate taxes a $10,000 deduction, and a married person filing separately with $8,000 a $5,000 deduction, as main did.

Mutants, each run against the one file that should catch it:

  • With the property tax cap starting in 2025, the 2019 case and both 2024 cases in mn_property_tax_deduction.yaml fail. The single filers deduct $7,000 where the statute gives $10,000, and the married person filing separately deducts $3,000 where it gives $5,000. The 2024 personal property case in mn_itemized_deductions.yaml fails too.
  • Without personal property taxes in the sum, all 18 cases in mn_property_tax_deduction.yaml fail. With a $10,000 cap for married people filing separately, 3 cases fail. Without the cap, test_property_tax_deduction_invariants fails for 2019, 2024 and 2026.
  • In the HF1938 repeal, reading capped_property_taxes fails the 2025 case ($30,000 where the statute gives $22,000). Dropping the Minnesota charitable amount fails the 2026 case ($23,500 where the statute gives $23,000).
  • Applying Minnesota's floor after the federal one fails 6 cases in mn_charitable_deduction.yaml and test_charitable_deduction_invariants[2026]. A 0.5% Minnesota floor, or the Minnesota amount in AMT, fails test_charitable_deduction_invariants[2026].
  • The federal deduction in Minnesota itemized deductions fails 2 cases in mn_itemized_deductions.yaml. In the charity subtraction, it fails 6 cases in mn_charitable_deduction.yaml.
  • Without the supplied charitable_deduction_before_floor, test_ca_mn_itemized_limitation_properties.py fails for 2026.

Microsimulation impact

We estimate that this branch raises Minnesota income tax by $54.4m in 2026 on the default dataset, for 259 sampled tax units (625,140 weighted), 258 of which pay more. It lowers household net income by $54.4m, for 248 sampled households (580,121 weighted). Under the property tax cap and the 1% charitable floor, Minnesota itemized deductions fall by $1.07bn for 309 tax units (663,890 weighted). Filers who itemize subtract those deductions from income before Minnesota's rates apply, so tax rises by far less than the deductions fall. The charity subtraction for filers who don't itemize falls by $218.2m (165 tax units, 455,790 weighted), and alternative minimum taxable income, which subtracts it, rises by $237.1m (174 tax units, 467,622 weighted). Federal income tax and the federal charitable deduction don't change. The default dataset holds no personal property taxes, so the cap applies to real estate taxes alone here. We compared main at b25d78faa3 with this branch at d3bb251c32.

Output Main total Change Records changed (weighted)
mn_income_tax $17.26bn +$54.4m 259 (625,140)
mn_itemized_deductions $22.04bn -$1.07bn 309 (663,890)
mn_charity_subtraction $1.18bn -$218.2m 165 (455,790)
mn_amt_taxable_income $321.9bn +$237.1m 174 (467,622)
charitable_deduction $335.2bn $0 0 (0)
state_income_tax $576.6bn +$54.4m 259 (625,140)
income_tax $2,594.9bn $0 0 (0)
household_benefits $2,060.1bn $0 0 (0)
household_net_income $17,246.4bn -$54.4m 248 (580,121)

Axiom

axiom: TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2303 queued (Minn. Stat. 290.0122, subds. 3(a)(1) and 4(a), and 290.0132, subd. 7; the corpus release that rulespec-us pins lacks both sections, so the signed encoder can't run yet)

rulespec-us#2017 queues section 290.0122, subd. 2(d)(1), and section 290.091, subd. 2(a), for investment interest. It quotes subd. 2(a)(2)(i), the clause the AMT choice follows.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

MaxGhenis and others added 3 commits November 13, 2026 08:12
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MaxGhenis and others added 7 commits November 14, 2026 11:35
Keep both new source-conflict candidates: South Dakota's hourly child
care cap from #10815 and Minnesota's AMT charitable floor.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The Legislature has capped the deduction for combined real estate and
personal property taxes at $10,000, or $5,000 for a married person filing
separately, since section 290.0122, subdivision 3(a)(1), took effect for
taxable years beginning after December 31, 2018 (Laws 2019, First Special
Session, chapter 6, article 1, section 16). Dating the cap from 2025 left
personal property taxes out of the deduction for 2019 through 2024.

A 2024 single filer with $7,000 of real estate taxes, $4,000 of personal
property taxes and $12,000 of mortgage interest now itemizes
12,000 + min(11,000, 10,000) = $22,000, up from $19,000. Results for
filers who pay only real estate taxes don't change before 2025, when the
federal cap was also $10,000 ($5,000).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…repeal

The repeal reform replaces mn_itemized_deductions with a formula that
added federally capped real estate taxes and kept the federal charitable
deduction. Against a baseline with Minnesota's $10,000 cap and 1% floor,
the repeal gave a 2025 single filer with $200,000 of wages, $18,000 of
real estate taxes and $12,000 of mortgage interest $30,000 of itemized
deductions, where the baseline gives $22,000.

The Legislature amended only subdivision 2 of section 290.0122 in House
File 1938 (Laws 2023, chapter 64), so the repeal now reads
mn_property_tax_deduction and the Minnesota charitable amount, as the
baseline does.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Replace the worker process and its hand-built tax-benefit system with two
grid tests on policyengine_us.Simulation, one simulation per year. The
worker listed about 35 variable files by path, so moving any of them
broke the test. The new checks take their caps, floors and years from the
statutes, and leave the amounts at each threshold to the YAML files.

Supply charitable_deduction_before_floor in the California and Minnesota
limitation test. From 2026 Minnesota applies its floor to that amount, so
the test's gift units deducted nothing in Minnesota. A third check now
fails if a gift doesn't raise the no-income deduction by its full amount.

Drop the federal output from the two zero-income Minnesota cases, which
supply the amount before the floor directly.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Replace the five one-line excerpts with the sources themselves: page 1 of
the draft 2026 Schedules M1MT and M1SA, sections 290.0122 and 290.091 in
full, and section 70425 of Public Law 119-21. Note in the candidate that
the conflict ends if the department takes the federal section 170 amount
on line 11 of its final 2026 Schedule M1MT.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Both sides split the federal charitable deduction formula. Keep
charitable_deduction_given_contribution_base from #9940, which Hawaii
calls with its own adjusted gross income, and split the ceilings out of
it as charitable_deduction_before_floor_given_contribution_base, which
charitable_deduction_before_floor now calls with federal positive AGI.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MaxGhenis and others added 2 commits November 14, 2026 23:43
Both sides appended cases to mn_itemized_deductions.yaml and the contrib
mn_walz_hf1938.yaml: #10070 its wagering-loss cases, this branch its
charitable and property tax cases. Keep every case from both sides,
main's first.

Git combined mn_itemized_deductions.py, the HF1938 reform and the
source-conflict candidates without conflict. The baseline and the
reform read mn_property_tax_deduction and mn_charitable_deduction, and
both leave wagering_losses_deduction out of the limitation.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Main added source-conflict candidates beside this branch's entries. Keep main's
entries in main's order and put this branch's entries after main's last entry
for the same jurisdiction.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@MaxGhenis

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

US + core hub merge audit, us#10872 at d3bb251c32b3e69641870c1b99b25a39f326d65f (squash): Apply Minnesota's charitable floor and property tax cap.

  • Reviews:
    • The PR has no GitHub reviews. Two independent review rounds ran outside GitHub, with a fix round between them, and a third review checked the first of the two merges of main that followed.
    • The first round, at 3b0a989b2f, read Minn. Stat. 290.0122, subds. 3(a)(1) and 4(a), 290.0132, subd. 7, 290.091, subd. 2(a)(2)(i), and 290.01, subd. 31. It also read section 70425 of Public Law 119-21 and the draft 2026 Schedules M1SA and M1MT. It computed ten households by hand and ran them on the head and on the merge base a93cc58d7e, and every result matched its hand figures.
    • It found the 1% floor and the AMT choice consistent with the statutes, and it requested three changes. The PR dated the property tax cap from 2025, where the Legislature has capped combined real estate and personal property taxes since tax year 2019. The HF1938 repeal reform kept the federal SALT limit and the federal floor, so a 2025 homeowner with $18,000 of real estate taxes showed a false $628 tax cut from the repeal. The description had no population estimate.
    • It also listed four minor findings. From 2026, Minnesota's amount dropped a federal charitable deduction that a caller supplied. Two zero-income cases pinned the federal formula's handling of a supplied input. The invariant test built its own tax-benefit system from hard-coded file paths. The register entry didn't say what would end the conflict.
    • The fix round, through 86ddcf0b00, dated the cap from 2019 and kept capped_property_taxes for earlier years, since PolicyEngine copies parameters back to 2015 and section 290.0122 took effect in 2019. It rewrote the two 2024 cases and added a 2019 case and a 2024 itemizer who pays personal property taxes. The HF1938 repeal now reads Minnesota's property tax deduction and charitable amount, with a 2025 and a 2026 case.
    • The same round replaced the invariant harness with ordinary simulation grids and dropped the federal output from the zero-income cases. It supplied the amount before the floor in the California and Minnesota limitation test, and it replaced the five source captures with official text. Each of twelve mutants failed a case or an invariant in every file it ran against.
    • Two merges of main came in that round. In 454078f3e4, Pay South Dakota CCA from the July 2024 hourly county rates #10815 had added a register entry at the same place as this PR's, and the merge keeps both. In c9f35d117c, Update Hawaii deductions for Act 35 conformity #9940 had added charitable_deduction_given_contribution_base to the federal file for Hawaii. The merge keeps main's function and formula and moves the ceiling steps into charitable_deduction_before_floor_given_contribution_base, which main's function calls before it applies the federal floor.
    • The second round raised no blocking finding at 86ddcf0b00. It read both merges hunk by hunk, fetched the statutes and the three session laws again, recomputed every changed expectation by hand and mapped each first-round finding to its fix. CI's run at that head passed every changed test file and the federal and Hawaii charitable files. It ran 18, 27, 11, 10 and 2 cases in the five Minnesota files, 34 federal and 10 Hawaii cases, 7 HF1938 cases, 1 reform case and the three Python files.
    • It listed two minor code findings, and both stay open under Next. The new federal variable copies the law.cornell.edu reference of main's charitable_deduction. A 2019 test comment names the statute's $194,650 reduction threshold, where the model uses $199,850 for 2019; the case has $50,000 of income, below both.
    • The second round listed corrections to the description, and I made each before merge. The description now says the invariant test checks each listed invariant, names the federal and Hawaii files that pin those amounts and states the federal floor's minimum of zero. It also says which thresholds the YAML cases pin for each filing status, and it compares the 2018 to 2024 real estate results with main's.
    • After the second round, bc14ef8325 merges main at a29c73d587, because Count gambling winnings in federal gross income and fix the wagering losses deduction #10070 added cases at the ends of mn_itemized_deductions.yaml and the contrib mn_walz_hf1938.yaml, where this PR adds its own. The merge keeps both sides' cases, main's first, so the files hold 29 and 8 cases. Count gambling winnings in federal gross income and fix the wagering losses deduction #10070 also added wagering_losses_deduction to the deductions that mn_itemized_deductions.py and the HF1938 reform leave out of the reduction, and a Minnesota entry to the register. Git combined those three files without conflict, and the register then held 465 unique ids. Main's three new Minnesota cases set no real estate taxes and no gifts, so this PR's formulas leave their expected values unchanged.
    • The third review raised no blocking finding at bc14ef8325. It compared the base, branch, main and merged copies of the five files both sides changed, and it recomputed main's three new cases by hand under the combined formulas. It listed two minor findings in lines that main added, which stay open under Next, and two case counts in the description, which I corrected.
    • After the third review, d3bb251c32 merges main at b25d78faa3, because Correct 2018–2020 Medicaid parent limits in UT, TN and VA and adult-group starts in UT and VA #10874 added three entries at the end of source_conflicts/candidates.yaml, where this PR's entry sat. In that merge, git combined every file but the register without conflict. The merge keeps main's 478 register entries in main's order and puts this PR's entry after main's last Minnesota entry, so the register holds 479 unique ids. A script checked that each entry matches its own side's text and that the merged tree differs from main in this PR's 27 files alone. Between a29c73d587 and b25d78faa3, main added 14 register entries and edited four, none for Minnesota. Correct 2018–2020 Medicaid parent limits in UT, TN and VA and adult-group starts in UT and VA #10874 also added seven Medicaid parameter files to KNOWN_UNMARKED in test_source_conflicts.py, and git combined them with this PR's line. In that range, main changed no Minnesota file and no charitable or itemized-deduction formula. Correct historical federal taxes and add annual 2017–2026 tests #10854 added 2017 values to the federal list of itemized deductions and to the non-itemizer charitable amount, and it changed no later value in either. Count strike benefits other than gifts in federal gross income #10727 counts strike benefits other than gifts in federal gross income, so AGI, the base of both floors, rises for a filer who receives them. None of this PR's cases sets strike benefits.
  • Methodology choices for maintainers:
    • Minnesota AMT keeps the federal section 170 deduction, with its 0.5% floor, under section 290.091, subd. 2(a)(2)(i). Line 11 of the department's draft 2026 Schedule M1MT takes Minnesota's amount from Schedule M1SA instead. For an itemizer with $100,000 of AGI and $4,000 of gifts, the statute gives $96,500 of alternative minimum taxable income and the draft form $97,000. source_conflicts/candidates.yaml records the conflict as us-mn:amt-charitable-contribution-floor, with state ruled under the statute-first principle. The conflict ends if the department's final schedule takes the federal amount.
    • The property tax cap starts in 2019, the first tax year of section 290.0122. Before 2019 the deduction returns capped_property_taxes, as main did, and no test pins a year before 2019.
    • The PR adds mn_personal_property_taxes, a Minnesota person input that defaults to zero, so existing datasets hold no values for it. The model had no general personal property tax input.
    • From 2026, Minnesota's charitable amount starts from charitable_deduction_before_floor. A caller who supplies only charitable_deduction gets no Minnesota charitable deduction from 2026. A fallback to the supplied federal amount plus the federal floor would add a new choice, and this PR doesn't make it.
    • Minnesota's floor uses positive_agi, federal AGI with a minimum of zero, as the contribution base. Section 170(b)(1)(H) also leaves out any net operating loss carryback, which the model doesn't hold.
    • The model covers current-year gifts. It has no charitable carryovers, which the draft Schedule M1SA adds after the floor, and no input for the qualified charitable distributions that sections 290.0122, subd. 4(a), and 290.0132, subd. 7, leave out.
    • The itemization choice still compares itemized deductions with the standard deduction before the non-itemizer subtraction. A filer the model has itemize could owe less with the standard deduction and the subtraction.
    • The HF1938 repeal reform keeps Minnesota's property tax cap and charitable amount, since the Legislature amended only subd. 2 of section 290.0122 in House File 1938 (Laws 2023, chapter 64).
  • Gates checked live at merge:
  • Impact: we estimate that this branch raises Minnesota income tax by $54.4m in 2026 on the default dataset, for 259 tax units (625,140 weighted), and lowers household net income by $54.4m. Under the property tax cap and the 1% charitable floor, Minnesota itemized deductions fall by $1.07bn (309 tax units, 663,890 weighted), and the charity subtraction for filers who don't itemize falls by $218.2m. Main b25d78faa3 against d3bb251c32.
  • Next:
    • Add North Carolina's wagering losses itemized deduction from 2025 (G.S. 105-153.5(a)(2)e) #10110 and Count railroad benefits in state tax worksheets, income tests and limits as each state's law does #10722, both drafts, edit the HF1938 reform, and Add North Carolina's wagering losses itemized deduction from 2025 (G.S. 105-153.5(a)(2)e) #10110 also edits mn_itemized_deductions.py and its cases. Tax railroad retirement benefits under IRC 86 and 72(r) and subtract them from state income #10696 edits mn_amt_taxable_income.py and its cases. After this squash, each should merge main and keep this PR's property tax and charitable lines and cases.
    • Add the federal scholarship tax credit under IRC §25F #10902, a draft, changes the cash input inside the federal ceiling steps, which this PR moves into charitable_deduction_before_floor_given_contribution_base. It should make that change in the helper, so the federal deduction and the amount before the floor both read it.
    • Separately, 35 other open PRs edit source_conflicts/candidates.yaml.
    • The conflict us-mn:amt-charitable-contribution-floor still needs its entry in the rulespec-us register, pinned to this squash. A follow-up PR then marks the deciding line in mn_amt_taxable_income.py, refreshes the pin and deletes the candidate and the file's KNOWN_UNMARKED line.
    • The HF1938 repeal reform's itemized deductions still differ from the baseline's. They keep mortgage insurance premiums, which section 290.0122, subd. 5(3), leaves out of interest. They also reduce investment interest, which subd. 2 exempted before and after House File 1938. An issue should port both rules, with a case for each.
    • For 2018, section 290.993 adjusts tax to the Internal Revenue Code as amended through December 16, 2016, and its list of excepted Public Law 115-97 sections leaves out section 11042, the SALT limit. The model caps 2018 real estate taxes at $10,000, and no test pins the 2018 rule.
    • reduction/agi_threshold/low.yaml starts in 2021 at $199,850, and PolicyEngine copies that value back to 2019 and 2020. The 2019 edition of subd. 2(b) set $194,650, indexed from 2020, so a 2019 filer between the two amounts gets no reduction in the model. The 2019 case's comment in mn_property_tax_deduction.yaml names the statute's amount.
    • Until Laws 2026, chapter 128, subd. 4(a) applied section 170(b)(1)(G) "regardless of the taxable year", and the model gives Minnesota the federal deduction before 2026. If the federal 2020 and 2021 election for cash gifts lifts the federal amount above the 60% ceiling, Minnesota's amount for those years may run too high. Nobody has checked this beyond the statute text.
    • charitable_deduction_before_floor.py copies the law.cornell.edu reference of main's charitable_deduction. A follow-up can move both to the House's code site.
    • Main's register note for us-mn:wagering-losses-itemized-limitation-exclusion cites lines 68 and 71 of mn_itemized_deductions.py and lines 136 and 139 of the HF1938 reform. This PR adds lines above them, so they move to 72 and 75 and to 144 and 147. A follow-up should name the exempt_deds list in each file instead.
    • Main's 2023 wagering case in mn_itemized_deductions.yaml sets capped_property_taxes to zero. From 2019, mn_property_tax_deduction reads real estate and personal property taxes, so that input no longer affects the case, which still expects $50,000.
    • The model lets a Minnesota itemizer deduct property taxes up to the full federal cap from 2025, where Minnesota allows $10,000 #10800 describes the cap from 2025. A comment there should record that the Legislature has capped combined real estate and personal property taxes since tax year 2019, and that this PR adds the personal property input.
    • I found no open issue for charitable carryovers, qualified charitable distributions or the itemization choice before the subtraction.
  • Axiom: Encode Minnesota's property tax deduction cap, 1% charitable floor and non-itemizer charity subtraction (Minn. Stat. 290.0122, subds. 3(a)(1) and 4(a), and 290.0132, subd. 7) (PE-US #10872) TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2303 queued, a new pe-parity issue for Minn. Stat. 290.0122, subds. 3(a)(1) and 4(a), and 290.0132, subd. 7, with companion rows from this PR's YAML. The signed encoder can't run yet: the corpus release that rulespec-us pins lacks both sections, and no Minnesota manifest in the corpus holds the two session laws that date the rules. Encode Minnesota's investment interest rules for the itemized deduction reduction and the AMT: Minn. Stat. § 290.0122, subd. 2(d)(1), and § 290.091, subd. 2(a) (PE-US PR 10645) TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2017 queued as it stands, since its 2024 row keeps its value.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

1 participant