Skip to content

Count public assistance and SSI supplements in New York CCAP income - #10827

Merged
MaxGhenis merged 15 commits into
mainfrom
ny-ccap-public-assistance-income
Nov 17, 2026
Merged

MaxGhenis merged 15 commits into
mainfrom
ny-ccap-public-assistance-income

Conversation

@MaxGhenis

@MaxGhenis MaxGhenis commented Nov 12, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

PolicyEngine now counts Family Assistance, reported Safety Net Assistance payments and adults' state SSI supplements in the income that sets New York child care assistance eligibility and family shares. OCFS counts these payments under 18 NYCRR 404.5(b)(5)(vi) (OCFS compilation, October 2023 text).

OCFS began excluding children's SSI and state supplements on October 1, 2023, through emergency rule CFS-42-23-00002-EP, and adopted the exclusion permanently, effective June 12, 2024. Before October 1, 2023, OCFS counted SSI and state supplements for every member (November 2021 text). PolicyEngine now counts a child's payments in each month before October 2023 and excludes them from October 2023 on. Main excluded children's SSI in every year.

OCFS excepts a family from the family share when a parent or caretaker relative receives public assistance (415.3(e)(1)). PolicyEngine now waives the share for a family that takes up a Family Assistance grant, as it does for a family that reports receipt, so a family whose grant counts as income pays no share.

For example, a New York County parent earns $12,000 in 2026, pays $1,000 a month in rent, and lives with a 4-year-old in care and a grandparent who receives $11,928 of SSI and no state supplement. The family receives $6,948 of Family Assistance, and its $30,876 of countable income exceeds the $27,320 state income standard for three by $3,556. The family reports no Family Assistance enrollment and pays no share. Without the waiver, it would pay the $4.33 monthly minimum.

This implements part 1 of #10239, covering CCAP income. Part 2 remains with the separate HEAP work.

Closes #10705

Merges of main

This branch includes main with #10817 and #10821. #10817 added the Safety Net Assistance and veteran assistance receipt inputs, the preventive care route, and the preventive care and child-only exceptions. The family share waiver reads the receipt inputs and both exceptions beside ny_ccap_family_assistance > 0.

#10821 has landed, and it also edited New York's child care note in policyengine_us/programs.yaml. We merged main and resolved that one conflict. We kept main's text on payment differentials, the special-needs rate and New York City's enhanced rates. We added this PR's sentence on counted income and dropped public assistance income from "Not modeled".

#10821 also raised New York City's enhanced informal part-day rate for a school-age child from $28 to $30. integration.yaml case 3 uses that rate beside this PR's declined grant and now expects $385.67 a month. That merge changes no other expected value in this PR's test files.

We then merged main again, kept main's source-conflict candidates in main's order and put this PR's candidate after main's last New York one.

Invariants

The property tests live in policyengine_us/tests/core/test_ny_ccap_public_assistance_income_invariants.py. The YAML cases live in ny_ccap_public_assistance_income.yaml and ny_ccap_family_share_exempt.yaml under policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/ny/ocfs/ccap/.

  • Countable income rises dollar for dollar with the Family Assistance a family takes up, the Safety Net Assistance amount and an adult's state supplement. test_countable_income_weakly_rises_with_each_public_assistance_source checks each source, and a declined grant adds nothing.
  • When all three amounts equal zero, countable income, the family share and CCAP equal main's results from 2024 on. test_zero_public_assistance_amounts_preserve_main_income_and_ccap compares this branch with a restatement of main's income formula across generated families in 2024, 2025 and 2026.
  • A child's SSI and supplement raise countable income by 12 months of payments in 2022, 9 months in 2023 and nothing in 2024. test_a_childs_ssi_and_supplement_count_only_before_october_2023 checks those counts, and YAML cases pin 2022 and 2023.
  • From 2024 on, a child's supplement changes neither countable income, the family share nor CCAP. test_a_childs_state_supplement_does_not_change_income_or_ccap checks that exclusion.
  • A family with reported Family Assistance enrollment pays no share, and its CCAP stays nonnegative. test_reported_public_assistance_keeps_the_family_share_zero checks those families, and a YAML case checks reported receipt with no computed grant.
  • The counted grant equals ny_tanf for a family that takes it up and zero otherwise, and every family with a counted grant pays no share. test_counted_family_assistance_keeps_the_family_share_zero checks families without reported enrollment. YAML cases check a three-person family above the state income standard with and without reported enrollment, and a family that declines the grant and pays its share.
  • A family that reports Safety Net Assistance receipt pays no share without Family Assistance. test_safety_net_receipt_alone_keeps_the_family_share_zero checks those families.
  • A family with a computed grant and child care expenses receives CCAP without the model requesting the federal tanf aggregate. test_computed_family_assistance_with_childcare_expenses_avoids_federal_tanf checks 2024, 2025 and 2026.
  • Abolishing TANF removes Family Assistance from countable income and leaves the other sources. ny_ccap_public_assistance_income_abolition.yaml checks that case.

Methodology choices

  • Count Family Assistance as ny_tanf for a family that takes it up, and as zero when gov.hhs.tanf.abolish_tanf applies. ny_ccap_family_assistance holds that amount. The federal tanf aggregate sums other states' programs, whose dependent care deductions read child care subsidies, so reading it would make CCAP depend on itself. A direct tanf input does not reach CCAP income; set ny_tanf instead.
  • Treat a Family Assistance grant the family takes up as a parent's or caretaker relative's receipt of public assistance under 415.3(e)(1). The SPM-unit grant does not say which members belong to the assistance unit, so a grant paid for children alone also waives the share. The public assistance reason-for-care route still reads reported receipt only, so a family with a computed grant and no reported receipt gets the share waiver and not that route.
  • Count the ny_safety_net_assistance amount as income without waiving the share. The SPM-unit amount can include another member's payments, so it does not show that a parent or caretaker relative receives them. The ny_safety_net_assistance_received input carries that fact. Household benefits and other programs' income leave the amount out.
  • Count an adult's ny_ssp beside the adult's SSI, and keep the is_child cutoff below age 18 for both payments. An 18-year-old's payments count.
  • Apply the child SSI exclusion month by month inside annual countable income. Monthly consumers read one twelfth of the annual total, so each 2023 month carries one twelfth of the payments counted from January to September.
  • ny_ssp amounts start on January 1, 2026, and the model copies each parameter's earliest value back to 2015. Supplements counted for years before 2026 therefore use the 2026 amounts.
  • Keep annual countable-income aggregation and the SPM unit as the family. This change adds no income-averaging period and no family-unit definition.
  • Record LII's copy of 404.5, which still shows the text in force before October 1, 2023, as us-ny:ccap-child-ssi-state-supplement-exclusion in source_conflicts/candidates.yaml. The candidate starts in 2023 and stays unreviewed. The captures under source_conflicts/sources/us-ny/ hold both OCFS compilations, LII's text and the three State Register notices.

We added the income sources to New York's coverage note and removed the public-assistance income omission. New York keeps its partial status and its other listed gaps.

We read web.archive.org copies of OCFS's Part 404 compilations, current as of November 24, 2021 and October 1, 2023, and of its Part 415 compilation, current as of February 13, 2024. Page anchors follow those copies. We could not reach ocfs.ny.gov, so we have not confirmed that its live copies match. The Department of State served the three State Register notices directly.

Test fixtures

TANF reads earnings before labor supply responses, employment_income_before_lsr. In a YAML case that enters employment_income, TANF counts no earnings. In three existing cases with working parents, CCAP therefore counted a Family Assistance grant: integration.yaml cases 5 and 6 and court_supervision.yaml case 8. Those cases now enter the earnings TANF reads.

Other cases enter no earnings, so PolicyEngine computes a grant that waives the share. Two integration.yaml cases decline the grant. Five existing ny_ccap_family_share_exempt.yaml cases, the 24 ny_ccap.yaml cases from #10817 without reported TANF enrollment, and the families in #10817's property tests set ny_tanf to zero. Seven of those ny_ccap.yaml cases expect a share and fail without the input. The other 17 expect the exemption through another exception, and a computed grant would supply it without that exception. Every expected value in those files stays the same.

Validation

Pull request run 43998058319 at 18112c6344 passed all 37 jobs on GitHub's merge with main 95d39697ef.

The changed test files, four more New York child care files and six repository checks pass with these counts:

File Result
ny_ccap_public_assistance_income.yaml 15 passed
ny_ccap_public_assistance_income_abolition.yaml 1 passed
ny_ccap_family_share_exempt.yaml 10 passed
ny_ccap.yaml 37 passed
integration.yaml 6 passed
court_supervision.yaml 9 passed
ny_ccap_countable_income.yaml 16 passed
ny_ccap_family_share.yaml 8 passed
ny_ccap_activity_eligible.yaml 9 passed
ny_ccap_income_eligible.yaml 4 passed
ny_ccap_eligible_child.yaml 14 passed
test_ny_ccap_public_assistance_income_invariants.py 10 passed
test_ny_ccap_categorical_routes_invariants.py 4 passed
test_source_conflicts.py 251 passed
test_programs_registry.py 912 passed, 9 skipped
test_parameter_yaml_keys.py, test_reference_urls.py, test_no_concatenated_reference_urls.py, test_aggregate_list_integrity.py 34, 32, 48 and 38 passed

Nine mutants, run at 3147d74c07, each fail at least one YAML case, and this head changes none of the files they alter:

  • the waiver reads only reported receipt;
  • the waiver applies at a zero grant;
  • the waiver drops reported Family Assistance enrollment;
  • the waiver drops Safety Net Assistance receipt;
  • the child exclusion applies in every year;
  • the child exclusion starts a month late;
  • the child exclusion follows the year's parameter value, not each month's;
  • the counted grant ignores take-up;
  • the counted grant ignores TANF abolition.

Ruff's format check and lint pass on the changed Python files.

Microsimulation impact

We estimate that this branch changes no household's child care subsidy, income taxes, benefits or net income in 2026 on the default dataset, where New York's child care subsidy totals $0 on main and on this branch. New York sets child care eligibility and the family share from countable income, and the branch raises that total by $1.66bn, for 69 sampled SPM units (819,683 weighted). We compared main at b25d78faa3 with this branch at 18112c6344.

Output Main total Change Records changed (weighted)
ny_ccap $0 $0 0 (0)
ny_ccap_countable_income $1,177.8bn +$1.66bn 69 (819,683)
ny_child_care_subsidies $0 $0 0 (0)
child_care_subsidies $1.72bn $0 0 (0)
state_income_tax $576.6bn $0 0 (0)
income_tax $2,594.9bn $0 0 (0)
household_benefits $2,060.1bn $0 0 (0)
household_net_income $17,246.4bn $0 0 (0)

axiom: TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2302 queued (18 NYCRR 404.5(b)(5)(vi) and (b)(6)(xxi) and 415.3(e)(1); the corpus lacks OCFS Parts 404 and 415, so the signed encoder can't run yet)

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

MaxGhenis and others added 6 commits November 12, 2026 00:37
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MaxGhenis and others added 3 commits November 13, 2026 19:39
… the child SSI exclusion

New York waives the child care family share when a parent or caretaker
relative receives public assistance (18 NYCRR 415.3(e)(1)). The waiver
read reported enrollment only, so a family whose computed Family
Assistance counted as income still paid a share. ny_ccap_family_assistance
now holds the ny_tanf grant the family takes up, zero when TANF is
abolished. Countable income counts it, and the waiver reads it beside
reported enrollment.

OCFS began excluding children's SSI and state supplements on October 1,
2023. Countable income now counts those payments in each month before
that date and excludes them from it.

The Safety Net Assistance input moves to the OTDA folder, and its
404.5(b)(5)(vi) entry follows (v) in the sources list. New York's coverage
note now says when children's payments count.

Two integration cases now enter earnings as employment_income_before_lsr,
which TANF reads. With employment_income alone, the YAML runner left TANF
with no earnings, and countable income counted the resulting grant.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
LII still reproduces the 404.5 text in force before October 1, 2023,
which matches OCFS's November 2021 compilation. The candidate now starts
in 2023, says so and cites that compilation. Its state moves from ruled
to unreviewed, since no ruling covers it. Each capture holds whole pages
of the source text in the format the other captures use.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
TANF reads employment_income_before_lsr, and the YAML runner does not
copy employment_income into it. The model therefore computed a Family
Assistance grant for this family with $60,000 of earnings and counted
the grant in CCAP income. The case now enters the earnings TANF reads,
and its expected values stay the same.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MaxGhenis and others added 3 commits November 14, 2026 09:23
Main now holds New York's categorical routes and family share exceptions
(#10817). Resolve two conflicts:

- programs.yaml: keep main's New York child care note, add the income
  sources this branch counts and drop the public assistance income gap
  this branch closes.
- ny_ccap_family_share_exempt.py: keep main's Safety Net Assistance,
  veteran assistance, preventive care and child-only exceptions, and read
  the Family Assistance grant the family takes up beside reported
  enrollment.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…lic assistance

Twenty-four ny_ccap.yaml cases, three ny_ccap_family_share_exempt.yaml
cases and the categorical-route property tests describe families without
Family Assistance but enter no earnings. PolicyEngine computes a grant
for those families, and that grant now waives the family share. Set
ny_tanf to zero in those fixtures, so each case tests the exception it
names. Seven of the ny_ccap.yaml cases expect a share, which a computed
grant waives. Every expected value stays the same.

Add a case in which reported Family Assistance receipt waives the share
with no computed grant. Run the Safety Net Assistance receipt property
test, which waited for the receipt input that main now has. Say in
ny_safety_net_assistance that household benefits and other programs'
income leave these payments out.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Main now holds South Dakota's hourly child care rates (#10815), whose
source-conflict candidate ends candidates.yaml, where this branch adds
New York's. Keep both candidates, South Dakota's first.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@MaxGhenis
MaxGhenis marked this pull request as ready for review November 14, 2026 19:31
OCFS excludes children's SSI and state supplements from child care
assistance income from October 1, 2023, under 18 NYCRR 404.5(b)(5)(vi)
and (b)(6)(xxi). The code follows that reading, which we record under
readings.statute, so pe_us.follows takes statute, as in South Dakota's
candidate. We keep gap-fill, as the file header defines it, for code
that follows a form where the statute is silent.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MaxGhenis and others added 2 commits November 14, 2026 23:49
Main now holds New York's payment differentials, special-needs rate and
New York City enhanced rates (#10821). Resolve one conflict:

- programs.yaml: keep main's New York child care note, add the income
  sources this branch counts and drop the public assistance income gap
  this branch closes.

Git merges candidates.yaml and the New York integration test without
conflict. Keep every candidate and case from both sides.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Main added source-conflict candidates beside this branch's entries. Keep main's
entries in main's order and put this branch's entries after main's last entry
for the same jurisdiction.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@MaxGhenis

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

US + core hub merge audit, us#10827 at 18112c634414d22b5d3a86c007c226f27cc2b3ce (squash): Count public assistance and SSI supplements in New York CCAP income.

  • Reviews:
    • The PR has no GitHub reviews. Two independent review rounds ran outside GitHub, with a fix round between them and a one-line fix after the second. A third review read the third merge of main, at 598989335c. No review read the fourth merge, at the head. Git's merge conflicted in the source-conflict register alone, and a script resolved that file and checked the result.
    • The first round, at 928dcd5bc1, read 18 NYCRR 404.5(b)(5)(vi) and fetched the State Register of October 18, 2023 from dos.ny.gov. It ran 16 households on the head and on the merge base 935b24ff4f, and the head matched its hand figures for the income sources.
    • It found that the model counted a computed Family Assistance grant as income while the 415.3(e)(1) waiver read reported enrollment alone. For example, a 2025 family with a parent who earned $12,000, a 4-year-old in care and a grandparent on SSI paid a $4.33 monthly share on that head and none on the merge base.
    • It also found that the exclusion of a child's SSI and state supplement ran from 2021, where OCFS added it on October 1, 2023, and that the description gave no impact estimate. Its minor points included the source-conflict record, which framed LII's older copy as a competing reading, a YAML case that passed with the waiver off, and the folder and reference of ny_safety_net_assistance.
    • The fix round, from 6483a99ef6 to bc953cfee5, added ny_ccap_family_assistance, which countable income and the waiver both read. It dated the child exclusion with a parameter that turns true on October 1, 2023, and the annual formula reads that parameter month by month. It started the source-conflict candidate in 2023, replaced the capture fragments with full pages and moved ny_safety_net_assistance under otda.
    • That round found three existing cases that already failed at 928dcd5bc1: integration.yaml cases 5 and 6 and court_supervision.yaml case 8. They entered employment_income, which TANF doesn't read, so CCAP counted a grant. They now enter the earnings TANF reads.
    • It merged main twice. The first merge, after Fix New York child care categorical routes and family shares #10817, resolved conflicts in programs.yaml and ny_ccap_family_share_exempt.py and kept all six of main's exceptions beside the new grant term. With main's fixtures, seven ny_ccap.yaml cases and two property tests failed, since a computed grant waived the share. The round set a zero grant in the cases without reported TANF enrollment and changed no expected value. The second merge resolved one conflict in source_conflicts/candidates.yaml.
    • Nine mutants each failed a YAML case at 3147d74c07. They covered the waiver's grant, enrollment and Safety Net Assistance terms, the exclusion's start date and monthly read, take-up and TANF abolition. The head changes none of the mutated files.
    • The second round raised no blocking finding at bc953cfee5. It fetched Internet Archive copies of OCFS's Part 404 compilations of November 2021 and October 2023 and of its Part 415 compilation. It fetched the State Registers of October 18, 2023 and June 12, 2024 from dos.ny.gov. It computed the grant household, the declined grant and a child's 2022 and 2023 payments by hand, and each matched the YAML.
    • It read both merges with git show --remerge-diff and found both sides intact in the three conflicted files. It read CI at that head, where all 36 jobs passed and the logs showed each changed test file. It confirmed by reading the cases that each of the nine mutants has a failing case.
    • It listed two minor findings. The description's example left out that the grandparent receives no state supplement. The source-conflict candidate said follows: gap-fill, where the code follows OCFS's regulation. cf5d1c1bc6 changes that value to statute, one line that touches no formula, value or test case, and CI passed all 36 jobs at that head.
    • After Add New York CCAP differentials and enhanced payment rates #10821 landed, a third merge brought main at a29c73d587 into the branch, at 598989335c. It resolved one conflict, in the New York CCAP note of programs.yaml. The merged note keeps main's text on differentials and enhanced rates, adds this PR's sentence on counted income and drops public assistance income from "Not modeled". Git merged integration.yaml and source_conflicts/candidates.yaml without conflict. In integration.yaml case 3, Add New York CCAP differentials and enhanced payment rates #10821's $30 New York City rate sits beside this PR's declined grant, and the case expects $385.67 a month. In candidates.yaml, main's side added eight candidates, Count gambling winnings in federal gross income and fix the wagering losses deduction #10070's Minnesota one among them, and edited ten. That merge's file held main's 464 candidates and this PR's one. This PR's other 22 files match cf5d1c1bc6 byte for byte.
    • The third review raised no finding against that merge. It read the merge with git show --remerge-diff and parsed candidates.yaml on both sides. It recomputed four integration.yaml cases and four public assistance cases by hand from the merged formulas, and each matched the YAML. It read CI at 598989335c, where all 37 jobs passed and the logs showed each changed test file.
    • That merge brought Add New York CCAP differentials and enhanced payment rates #10821's rewrite of ny_ccap, which sums a payment rate: the lesser of expenses and the market rate, times one plus a differential, with a cap for legally exempt group care. Add New York CCAP differentials and enhanced payment rates #10821's rate variables read no income, TANF or SSI variable, and this PR's variables read no rate variable. No case of this PR's that expects a benefit sets a differential, so each still prices care at the lesser of expenses and the market rate. The merge also brought Apply SSI's general exclusion once under spousal deeming #10837, which changed SSI for a claimant with in-kind support and income deemed from an ineligible spouse. This PR counts ssi and ny_ssp, so that claimant's family counts main's amounts in CCAP income. The review found four cases of this PR's that compute SSI for an eligible person, and each pins countable income or asserts age eligibility alone.
    • A fourth merge brought main at b25d78faa3 into the branch, at 18112c6344. Since a29c73d587, main had added 14 candidates to source_conflicts/candidates.yaml and edited four (Apply dependent-filer rules in DC, Georgia and Idaho, set DC's 2026 child credit to $0, credit Georgia ITIN children, require a qualifying individual for Idaho's care deduction and count only filers' Schedule H inputs #10050, Fix Arkansas tax indexing and Kentucky's 2021 dependent care credit #10324, Correct 2018–2020 Medicaid parent limits in UT, TN and VA and adult-group starts in UT and VA #10874, Count strike benefits other than gifts in federal gross income #10727 and Limit school meal categorical eligibility to each qualifying child #10838). Correct 2018–2020 Medicaid parent limits in UT, TN and VA and adult-group starts in UT and VA #10874 put three at the end of the file, where this PR's candidate sat, so git's merge conflicted there and in no other file. A script resolved that file. It kept main's 478 candidates in main's order and put this PR's one after main's last New York candidate. It checked that the merged file holds 479 unique ids and that each entry equals its own side's. Git merged programs.yaml without conflict and kept main's edit to the federal income tax entry (Correct historical federal taxes and add annual 2017–2026 tests #10854) beside this PR's New York note.
    • Main's side of the fourth merge changed no file under New York's ocfs or otda folders or under gov/ssa, and its only TANF files hold Colorado's grant history (Correct historical Colorado Works grant amounts and dates #10892). Two of its changes touch variables that New York child care variables read. Use exact 2016 HHS poverty guideline tables #10886 gave spm_unit_fpg, the state income standard, HHS's published table for 2016 alone, and this PR's cases cover 2022 to 2026. Count strike benefits other than gifts in federal gross income #10727 added documentation and a reference to strike_benefits, a counted income source, and changed nothing else in it.
    • The reviews listed corrections to the description, and I made each before merge. The example now says the grandparent receives no state supplement, the axiom: line names a queued issue and the validation section cites CI. The description also links government sources and the PR's own captures in place of archive links.
  • Methodology choices for maintainers:
    • A grant the family takes up waives the share even when it covers the children alone. Under 415.3(e)(1), OCFS excepts "a family where the parent(s) or caretaker relative(s) is receiving public assistance". The model sizes one grant for the SPM unit and holds no assistance-unit membership, so it can't tell a child-only grant from a family grant. The second review recommended this choice.
    • The public assistance reason for care reads reported receipt alone, as on main. A family with a computed grant and no reported receipt counts as a public assistance family for the share and not for the 415.2(a)(1) route. The second review recommended this for this PR, since the route also needs the required-activity input, which defaults to false.
    • The model counts the grant it computes for a family that takes it up, and takes_up_tanf_if_eligible defaults to true. A family with a computed grant and no reported enrollment therefore counts the grant as income and pays no share.
    • The Safety Net Assistance amount counts as income and doesn't waive the share, since it can include payments to a member other than a parent or caretaker relative. The receipt input from Fix New York child care categorical routes and family shares #10817 carries the waiver. Household benefits and other programs' income leave the amount out.
    • The child exclusion covers a member under 18, and an 18-year-old's SSI and supplement count. Neither 404.5(b)(5)(vi) nor (b)(6)(xxi) gives an age. Under 415.1(l), OCFS treats a person of 18 or older as an adult "unless the individual meets the definition of a child with special needs" or the district includes 18- to 20-year-olds in a parent's unit. Neither review report compares the cutoff with 415.1(l).
    • The model applies the exclusion in every month from October 2023. The notices in the PR's captures date from October 2023, February 2024 and June 2024. The February notice says its emergency rule expires on April 12, 2024. The State Register of May 1, 2024 carries readoption CFS-42-23-00002-E, effective April 11, 2024, which expires on June 9, 2024, three days before the adoption took effect. The PR's captures hold neither that issue nor any readoption between the October and February notices.
    • The annual formula applies the exclusion month by month, and a monthly reader gets one twelfth of the annual total. Each 2023 month therefore carries one twelfth of the payments counted from January to September.
    • ny_ssp amounts start on January 1, 2026, and the model copies each parameter's earliest value back to 2015. Supplements counted for earlier years therefore use the 2026 amounts. The backdating predates this PR.
    • Countable income stays annual and the SPM unit stays the family. The model applies neither the averaging period of 404.5(b)(2) and (3) nor the child care services unit of 415.1(l).
    • The source-conflict candidate us-ny:ccap-child-ssi-state-supplement-exclusion stays unreviewed. It records that LII's copy of 404.5 still shows the text in force before October 1, 2023.
  • Gates checked live at merge:
  • Impact: we estimate that this branch changes no household's child care subsidy, income taxes, benefits or net income in 2026 on the default dataset, where New York's child care subsidy totals $0 on both sides. It raises New York's CCAP countable income by $1.66bn (69 SPM units, 819,683 weighted). Main b25d78faa3 against 18112c6344.
  • Next:
    • The oracle in test_defaults_preserve_main_except_public_assistance_activity prices a homeless family's benefit as the lesser of expenses and the market rate, without Add New York CCAP differentials and enhanced payment rates #10821's homelessness differential. CI passes on the test's fixed draws, and main carries the same oracle. An issue can add the differential to it.
    • An optional issue can make the public assistance reason for care read the computed grant, as the share waiver does. The second review found that ny_tanf reads no child care input, so that read adds no cycle.
    • An issue can add an input that splits Family Assistance receipt by assistance unit. The waiver could then tell a child-only grant from one that includes a parent or caretaker relative.
    • An issue can add ny_safety_net_assistance to household benefits, since the amount now reaches CCAP income alone.
    • An issue can add New York's supplement schedules for years before 2026, so ny_ssp stops using 2026 amounts for earlier years.
    • YAML cases that enter employment_income give TANF no earnings, since TANF reads employment_income_before_lsr. An issue can check other states' child care files for cases that compute a grant this way.
    • The model has no input for a veteran assistance payment, so CCAP income counts none. An issue can add the amount beside the receipt input from Fix New York child care categorical routes and family shares #10817.
    • An issue can decide whether the child exclusion should reach a member of 18 or older whom 415.1(l) doesn't treat as an adult.
    • A reader with browser access to ocfs.ny.gov can check the current Parts 404 and 415 against the archived compilations. The State Register issues between October 2023 and February 2024, and those of June 2024, can confirm that the exclusion stayed in force.
    • The candidate us-ny:ccap-child-ssi-state-supplement-exclusion waits in the backlog as unreviewed. Once someone rules on it, the rulespec-us register takes the entry, pinned to this squash commit.
  • Axiom: Encode New York child care assistance income: public assistance, SSI and state supplements, the child exclusion from October 2023 and the Family Assistance share exception (18 NYCRR 404.5(b)(5)(vi), 404.5(b)(6)(xxi) and 415.3(e)(1)) (PE-US #10827) TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2302 queued, a new pe-parity issue for 18 NYCRR 404.5(b)(5)(vi) and (b)(6)(xxi) and the Family Assistance term of 415.3(e)(1), with companion rows from this PR's YAML. A comment on Encode New York child care assistance: the public assistance and Title XX preventive routes and family share exceptions (Social Services Law §§ 2(19) and 410-w; 18 NYCRR 404.5 and 415.1-415.3) (PE-US #10817) TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2225 pins its 26 companion rows to this head, where 23 gain a $0 grant input. The signed encoder can't run yet: the corpus holds no OCFS Part 404 or Part 415 and none of the three State Register issues that date the child exclusion.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

New York CCAP: count public assistance in countable income

1 participant