Skip to content

Apply dependent-filer rules in DC, Georgia and Idaho, set DC's 2026 child credit to $0, credit Georgia ITIN children, require a qualifying individual for Idaho's care deduction and count only filers' Schedule H inputs - #10050

Merged
MaxGhenis merged 47 commits into
mainfrom
claimable-filer-dc-ga-id
Nov 15, 2026

Conversation

@MaxGhenis

@MaxGhenis MaxGhenis commented Oct 10, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Summary

Apply District of Columbia, Georgia and Idaho rules for a filer whom another taxpayer can claim as a dependent. We keep three facts apart in each formula: whether someone can claim the filer, whether someone does, and whether the federal filing exception applies.

Four changes also reach filers nobody can claim:

  • From 2026, we set DC's child tax credit to $0 per child for every family, where main paid $1,000 and uprated it in later years. The Council revived the credit in a temporary act that expired on September 25, 2026.
  • A Georgia resident child with an ITIN qualifies for the 2026 child credit: $0 becomes $250.
  • We allow Idaho's household and dependent care deduction only with a qualifying individual under IRC 21(b)(1), and count only qualifying care.
  • For DC's Schedule H credit we count the head's and spouse's rent and property tax, and leave out amounts that a dependent in the tax unit holds.
Program Change
DC Schedule H property tax credit Bar a dependent under 65 from claiming the credit. A couple claims through either eligible spouse, with the couple's whole rent and the home's whole tax bill.
DC EITC without a qualifying child Deny the credit when another taxpayer can claim either filer, outside the filing exception. Main applied no dependency test.
DC Keep Child Care Affordable credit and child tax credit child Treat a filer whom another taxpayer can claim as having no dependents, outside the filing exception.
DC child tax credit amount $0 from 2026.
Georgia child credit Deny it for the child of a filer whom another taxpayer can claim, outside the filing exception. Allow it for a child with an ITIN.
Georgia dependent exemptions Allow none on a return whose filer another taxpayer can claim, outside the filing exception.
Georgia low income credit Exclude a filer whom another taxpayer claims or can claim, and count no child units for a dependent filer.
Georgia HB 162 surplus refund Exclude a filer whom another taxpayer claimed for 2021, unless that filer had positive wages, self-employment profit, farm profit or partnership earnings.
Idaho food tax credit Exclude a filer whom another taxpayer claims, in every year, and the dependents of a filer whom another taxpayer can claim, outside the filing exception. Main applied no dependency test.
Idaho 2022 rebate floor Count $75 for each filer, and for each dependent only when no other taxpayer can claim a filer, outside the filing exception.
Idaho household and dependent care deduction Require an IRC 21(b)(1) qualifying individual, and count only qualifying care.

The federal filing exception covers a filer whose would-be claimant files no return, or files only for a refund of withheld or estimated tax (Publication 596, pages 17-18; Publication 501, page 11).

Sources and readings

# Reading Sources
1 Georgia low income credit: a joint couple under 65 at $5,000 AGI keeps 2 × $26 = $52 when one spouse qualifies. Georgia lawmakers deem each joint spouse a dependent. 48-7A-3(a)(1), HB 1069 (2010) section 5
2 Georgia surplus refund: a joint return with $600 of 2021 liability keeps min($500, $600) = $500 when either spouse qualifies. Lawmakers define the qualified taxpayer per individual and set the amount by filing status. HB 162, 48-7-20.2(a)-(b)
3 Idaho food tax credit: a spouse nobody claims keeps $155 in 2025 when another taxpayer claims the other spouse. A single filer whom someone could claim, but nobody claims, keeps $100 in 2021, $120 in 2023 and $155 in 2025. Idaho lawmakers grant the credit for the taxpayer and spouse in (1) and allow one credit per personal exemption in (4). The form and instructions exclude anyone whom another taxpayer can claim. Code 63-3024A(1), (4); Form 40 line 12c; instructions, line 43
4a Georgia child credit: the child of a filer whom another taxpayer can claim moves from $250 to $0, outside the filing exception. Georgia lawmakers import IRC 24(c). Under 24(c)(2), the child must remain a dependent once 152(b)(3)(A) loses its words after "resident of the United States". Under 152(b)(1), a dependent taxpayer has no dependents. HB 136, 48-7-29.27(a); IRC 24(c); IRC 152(b)
4b Georgia child credit: an otherwise qualifying resident child with an ITIN moves from $0 to $250, with enough liability. Lawmakers adopted 24(c) without 24(h)(7)'s Social Security number test, and DOR repeats the 24(c) definition. HB 136; DOR, Qualifying Child Credit
5a Schedule H: dependent status bars a claimant under 65, whether or not anyone claims that person. The Council bars "the person claiming the credit" who "was a dependent" and defines a dependent by IRC 152. OTR's instructions name only a person whom another return claims. 47-1806.06(k); 47-1801.04(13); Schedule H, page 4
5b Schedule H: either eligible spouse may claim for the couple, at that spouse's age. The Council allows one claimant per tax filing unit, so one spouse's dependency leaves the other spouse's claim standing. 47-1806.06(b)(4), (b)(9)
5c Schedule H: a dependent under 65 with the federal filing exception moves from $1,425 to $0. The exception lets that filer claim their own dependents; the filer remains a dependent under (k). 47-1806.06(k); Publication 501, page 11
5d Schedule H: count the couple's whole rent, whichever spouse holds the input. Two $5,000 inputs at $10,000 AGI give min($1,425, $2,000 − $300) = $1,425, as on main. 47-1806.06(b)(8)(A), (j)(1); Schedule H, page 5
5e Schedule H: an owner claims the home's whole tax bill. Two $1,500 co-owner inputs at $20,000 AGI give min($1,425, $3,000 − $600) = $1,425. 47-1806.06(e)(1); Schedule H, page 5
6 DC EITC without a qualifying child: deny the credit when another taxpayer can claim either filer, outside the filing exception. The Council requires federal section 32 eligibility, and the IRS applies the dependency rule to both spouses on a joint return. OTR's worksheet asks only unmarried filers and married filers who file apart. 47-1806.04(f)(1)(C)(i); IRC 32(c)(1)(A)(ii)(III); Publication 596, pages 17-18; D-40 booklet, page 24
7 DC child tax credit: $0 from 2026. The Council repealed the credit as of October 1, 2024, then revived it at $1,000 for 2026 in a temporary act that took effect on February 12, 2026 and expired 225 days later. The Attorney General expects the temporary act not to govern calendar-year 2026 liabilities. The Code's page for 47-1806.17 still prints the 2024 text, without Law 26-55's repeal. Law 26-55, sections 7062-7063; Law 26-89, sections 2(j), 6(b); Attorney General opinion, page 2
8 Georgia surplus refund: a filer whom another taxpayer claimed for 2021 qualifies with positive wages, self-employment profit, farm profit or partnership earnings, before a loss from another source offsets them. A filer with $1,000 of wages, a $1,000 business loss and $600 of 2021 tax on other income, such as interest, keeps min($250, $600) = $250. Lawmakers wrote "had earned income for the 2021 taxable year" and imported no federal netting rule. HB 162, 48-7-20.2(a)(2)

Methodology choices

Each choice below has more than one defensible reading. source_conflicts/candidates.yaml records each one that sets one source against another.

  • Count the head's and spouse's rent together for Schedule H (5d), as main does. The Council defines rent paid as the amount "paid by a claimant to a landlord", makes a married couple one tax filing unit and allows that unit one claimant. OTR asks for "the total rent you paid for the property". Neither source splits a couple's rent by payer. DTrim99's review (Suggestion 1) called per-payer rent defensible for split inputs. PolicyEngine's US microdata assigns a household's rent and property tax to the household head. Per-payer rent would therefore cut a couple's credit from $1,425 to $0 when the head holds $30,000 of rent at 69, the spouse has reached 70 and AGI equals $80,000.
  • Give the filing unit the home's tax bill when an eligible claimant holds a property tax input (5e). The Council ties the bill to a claimant who "owns and occupies his or her home". The inputs carry no title field, so a positive property tax input identifies an owner. A home whose only property tax input sits on a dependent under 65 gives $0, as DTrim99's review (C1) asked. Rent carries no such test: the eligible spouse claims rent that the dependent spouse holds ($900 in the test case).
  • Count only the head's and spouse's rent and property tax for Schedule H. Main summed every tax unit member's inputs. The Council ties rent to the claimant and defines the tax filing unit as an individual or a married couple. A tax unit whose rent input sits on a dependent, such as a household head whom the filers claim, draws no credit from that rent.
  • Follow the Council's dependent definition over the wording of OTR's Schedule H instructions (5a, 5c). Candidate us-dc:schedule-h-claimable-unclaimed-claimant.
  • Follow the incorporated federal rule over the omission in OTR's EITC worksheet (6). Candidate us-dc:eitc-joint-dependent-worksheet-omission.
  • Read 24(c)(2) by its words for Georgia's child credit (4a): the counterfactual changes only the citizenship condition and leaves 152(b)(1) in force. A reading from the paragraph's heading alone would limit the exclusion to noncitizen children and keep $250, as main does. DOR's page repeats the 24(c) definition and addresses neither reading. Candidate us-ga:child-credit-dependent-filer-child stays state: open.
  • Count each positive source of wages, self-employment profit, farm profit or partnership earnings for Georgia's surplus refund (8). Netting a loss against wages, as federal earned income under IRC 32(c)(2)(A) does, would give $0 in reading 8's example. No Georgia source addresses netting. Candidate us-ga:surplus-refund-earned-income-loss-offset stays state: open.
  • Read "not claimed or ... not otherwise eligible to be claimed" in Georgia's low income credit as one exclusion that reaches a filer whom someone could claim but nobody claims, as DOR's booklet does. The literal disjunction would give that filer $26. Candidate us-ga:low-income-credit-claimed-or-eligible-disjunction.
  • Exclude an Idaho food tax credit filer in every year only when another taxpayer claims them, under 63-3024A(4). For 2015 to 2022, candidate us-id:grocery-credit-claimability-before-2023 stays state: open. The commission's rule then required a "permitted and claimed" personal exemption, and through 2018 the statute tied the credit to section 151. From 2023, candidates us-id:grocery-credit-claimable-unclaimed-filer and us-id:grocery-credit-claimable-spouse set the statute against Form 40.

Computations

We take the larger Schedule H credit among eligible claimants. Each claimant's credit uses the filing unit's rent and tax bill, the filing unit's AGI and that claimant's age. Under 70, the 2025 offset equals 3% of AGI up to $25,000 of AGI, 4% up to $52,000 and 5% up to the $66,000 limit. From 70, it equals 3% up to the $90,000 limit.

Case Computation Expected
2021 couple, 69 and 67, rent inputs $8,000 and $4,000, AGI $40,000 20% × $12,000 − 4% × $40,000 $800
2021 couple, 69 and 70, rent inputs $8,000 and $4,000, AGI $40,000 20% × $12,000 − 3% × $40,000 $1,200
2025 couple, 69 and 70, the spouse aged 69 holds $30,000 rent, AGI $80,000 min($1,425, 20% × $30,000 − 3% × $80,000) $1,425
2021 couple, 69 and 70, the spouse aged 69 holds $12,000 rent, AGI $40,000 20% × $12,000 − 3% × $40,000 $1,200
2025 couple, 69 and 70, rent inputs $12,000 and $1,000, AGI $40,000 20% × $13,000 − 3% × $40,000 $1,400
2025 couple, the dependent spouse holds $6,000 rent, AGI $10,000 20% × $6,000 − 3% × $10,000 $900
2025 co-owners with $1,500 each, AGI $20,000 min($1,425, $3,000 − 3% × $20,000) $1,425
2025 owners, 69 and 70, the spouse aged 69 holds a $3,000 bill, AGI $70,000 $3,000 − 3% × $70,000 $900
2025 home with a $3,000 bill on a dependent spouse under 65 No eligible claimant holds a property tax input $0
Same home with that spouse aged 65, AGI $20,000 min($1,425, $3,000 − 3% × $20,000) $1,425
2025 head with a $1,000 bill, child with a $2,000 input, AGI $20,000 $1,000 − 3% × $20,000 $400
2025 head with no rent, child with a $10,000 rent input 20% × $0 − 3% × $10,000, floored at zero $0

Four Schedule H cases for couples that main already carried keep main's values: $800, $1,200, $1,190 and $1,120.

A DC filer aged 30 with $1,000 of wages and the filing exception keeps the EITC without a qualifying child: 7.65% × $1,000 = $76.50. Without the exception the same filer gets $0.

Georgia denies the child credit in the five dependent-filer examples: 0 qualifying children × $250 = $0. The control with no dependent filer keeps $250, and the filing-exception control keeps min(1 × $250, $10,000 liability) = $250. The optional refundable child credit reform inherits the child definition.

For HB 162, a single filer whom another taxpayer claimed for 2021 receives min($250, $600 liability) = $250 with positive wages, self-employment profit, farm profit or partnership earnings. A loss alone gives $0. A child nobody claims cannot qualify a return whose two filers both fail: min($500, $600) × 0 = $0.

Idaho's single filer whom someone could claim, but nobody claims, receives $100 in 2021, $120 in 2023 and $155 in 2025, each for twelve qualifying months. Main paid the same amounts. A single filer whom another taxpayer claims receives $0 in 2022, where main paid $100. When nobody claims either adult and the filing exception restores the child, a 2025 household receives 3 × $155 = $465.

An Idaho filer whose only child has reached 14 has no IRC 21(b)(1) qualifying individual, so the care deduction equals 0 × min($1,000 expenses, $12,000 cap, $10,000 earnings) = $0. A qualifying disabled adult leaves a child's nonqualifying daycare out of the deduction.

Invariants

  • Swapping the head and spouse labels leaves every changed output the same.
  • Marking one more filer as claimed never raises an output that no tax liability caps.
  • A return with a filer whom another taxpayer can claim, outside the filing exception, has no DC Keep Child Care Affordable credit, no DC child tax credit and no Georgia child credit, and neither child predicate holds.
  • A Georgia return on which another taxpayer can claim every filer has no low income credit.
  • On a return with a filer whom another taxpayer can claim, outside the filing exception, Idaho's food tax credit never exceeds the per-person amount times the number of filers nobody claims.
  • The filing exception restores DC's $1,000 Keep Child Care Affordable credit, Georgia's $250 child credit and Idaho's $465 food tax credit under both labels.
  • DC's 2026 child tax credit stays $0.
  • For a DC couple nobody can claim, Schedule H gives the same credit whichever spouse holds the rent or property tax input.

policyengine_us/tests/core/test_claimable_filer_dc_ga_id_invariants.py checks the first five for a seeded population of couples in each of 2021, 2023, 2025 and 2026. Hypothesis couples drawn from those years check the first, third, fourth and fifth. One crafted couple with a two-year-old checks the sixth and seventh under both labels: in Idaho for 2025, and in DC and Georgia for 2026. The file checks the last one for 36 seeded DC couples in 2021 and 2025: it moves all rent and property tax to each spouse in turn and compares the credit.

In CI run 43605812303, Python shard 3 runs its 1,025 tests in 33 minutes. This file's ten tests take 64.3 seconds of that, and the two holder tests take 3.4 seconds each. The job log reports no peak memory.

Tests

Each file ran in its own process.

Test file Passed Failed
policyengine_us/tests/policy/contrib/states/dc/property_tax/dc_property_tax_credit.yaml 20 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/ga/tax/income/credits/ga_ctc.yaml 13 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/dc/tax/income/ctc/dc_ctc.yaml 10 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/dc/tax/income/ctc/dc_ctc_eligible_child.yaml 9 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/dc/tax/income/dc_cdcc.yaml 11 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/dc/tax/income/dc_kccatc.yaml 12 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/ga/tax/income/credits/dependent_care_credit/ga_cdcc.yaml 9 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/ga/tax/income/credits/ga_low_income_credit.yaml 14 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/ga/tax/income/exemptions/ga_exemptions.yaml 17 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/id/tax/income/credits/id_2022_rebate.yaml 7 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/id/tax/income/credits/id_ctc.yaml 15 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/id/tax/income/deductions/household_and_dependent_care/id_household_and_dependent_care_expense_deduction.yaml 18 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/contrib/dc_kccatc.yaml 4 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/id/tax/income/credits/grocery/integration.yaml 1 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/id/tax/income/integration.yaml 7 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/tax/income/state_income_tax_rebate_adjustment.yaml 44 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/dc/tax/property/senior_disabled_property_tax_relief/dc_senior_disabled_property_tax_relief.yaml 4 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/dc/tax/income/dc_ptc.yaml 33 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/id/tax/income/credits/grocery/id_grocery_credit.yaml 14 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/dc/tax/income/dc_eitc.yaml 33 0
policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/ga/tax/income/credits/ga_surplus_tax_rebate.yaml 31 0
policyengine_us/tests/core/test_claimable_filer_dc_ga_id_invariants.py 10 0
policyengine_us/tests/code_health/test_source_conflicts.py 103 0
Total, 23 files 439 0

The local runs left out two changed files, the contributed Georgia reform tests policyengine_us/tests/policy/contrib/states/ga/dependent_exemption_reform_test.yaml and policyengine_us/tests/policy/contrib/states/ga/ctc/ga_ctc_reform.yaml.

Pull request run 43676088399 at 1f19639860 passed all 37 jobs on GitHub's merge with main a29c73d587.

The Schedule H, Idaho food credit and Georgia refund formulas from 1fbc1c2473 fail 15 of these cases: 12 for Schedule H, 1 for Idaho and 2 for Georgia. They also fail 2 of the invariant file's 10 tests.

Mutants

Each edit ran against the named test file in its own process. Every edit failed at least one case.

Edit Test file Cases failed
Give each spouse only the rent that spouse holds dc_ptc.yaml 11
Give each spouse only the rent that spouse holds test_claimable_filer_dc_ga_id_invariants.py 2
Give the tax bill only to the spouse who holds the input dc_ptc.yaml 1
Claim the tax bill when only a dependent under 65 holds the input dc_ptc.yaml 1
Use the head's age for both spouses dc_ptc.yaml 5
Count a dependent's rent input dc_ptc.yaml 1
Count a dependent's property tax input dc_ptc.yaml 1
Drop the Schedule H dependent bar dc_ptc.yaml 4
Let the filing exception lift the Schedule H bar dc_ptc.yaml 1
Let a dependent in the tax unit claim Schedule H dc_ptc.yaml 2
Bar an Idaho filer whom someone could claim but nobody claims id_grocery_credit.yaml 3
Pay Idaho's credit to a filer whom another taxpayer claims id_grocery_credit.yaml 5
Ignore the filing exception for DC's EITC without a qualifying child dc_eitc.yaml 3
Ignore farm profit for HB 162 ga_surplus_tax_rebate.yaml 1
Ignore partnership earnings for HB 162 ga_surplus_tax_rebate.yaml 1
Net a loss against wages for HB 162 ga_surplus_tax_rebate.yaml 3

Ten more edits (eleven runs) ran at the earlier head 956534cd4d, and each failed its intended case. The lines they change read the same at this head.

  • Drop Georgia's child-credit dependency bar, against the baseline file and against the refundable reform file.
  • Restore Georgia's federal Social Security number test.
  • Apply the literal low-income disjunction.
  • Remove the HB 162 filer condition.
  • Ignore SSTB profit for HB 162.
  • Revive DC's $1,000 child credit.
  • Remove DC's joint EITC bar.
  • Drop the shared Schedule H filer condition, against the reform file.
  • Drop the claimant bar from the reform's phase-out.
  • Drop Idaho's qualifying-individual condition.

Follow-ups

  • Keep Georgia's adult-dependent unit count and food-stamp exclusion outside this change. PolicyEngine/policyengine-us#10659 tracks both.
  • Check ga_itemizer_credit_potential's reference to 48-7-29.23 against the itemizer provision.
  • Review Idaho's food tax credit for 2015 to 2018, when the statute granted the credit for each exemption that section 151 permitted.
  • Decide how Schedule H treats rent and property tax that a dependent household head holds. PolicyEngine's microdata puts both inputs on the household head, and this change counts only the filers' inputs.

Axiom parity

Comments on three rulespec-us issues re-pin them to this head and add the cases that changed since their earlier pins:

  • Schedule H's pooled rent and owner bill, its filing-exception claimant, the EITC filing-exception cases and DC's child credit amount of $0 from 2026 (#1701);
  • Georgia's $0 for the child of a filer whom another taxpayer can claim, and $250 for a child with an ITIN (#1702);
  • Idaho's food credit in 2021, 2022 and 2023 and for a 2025 filer whom nobody claims, and the care deduction's qualifying-individual case (#1703).

Two new issues queue Georgia's HB 162 refund under O.C.G.A. 48-7-20.2 (#2242) and Idaho's 2022 rebate floor under Idaho Code 63-3024B (#2243).

Microsimulation impact

We estimate that this branch raises state income tax by $107.2m in 2026 on the default dataset and lowers household net income by the same amount. DC's child tax credit falls from $100.7m to $0, for 91 sampled tax units (55,482 weighted). DC's property tax credit falls by $5.0m (2 tax units, 3,428 weighted), and Idaho income tax rises by $1.5m (3 tax units, 3,492 weighted). We compared main at 7acc38c2ac with this branch at 1f19639860.

Output Main total Change Records changed (weighted)
dc_ptc $110.4m -$5.0m 2 (3,428)
dc_ctc $100.7m -$100.7m 91 (55,482)
dc_eitc $119.5m $0 0 (0)
ga_ctc $124.4m +$3 4 (0)
id_grocery_credit $295.9m $0 0 (0)
dc_income_tax_before_refundable_credits $4.04bn $0 0 (0)
ga_income_tax $16.85bn -$3 4 (0)
id_income_tax $2.81bn +$1.5m 3 (3,492)
state_income_tax $576.5bn +$107.2m 99 (60,839)
income_tax $2,594.9bn $0 0 (0)
household_benefits $2,060.2bn $0 0 (0)
household_net_income $17,246.8bn -$107.2m 99 (60,839)

axiom: TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#1701 queued (DC: Schedule H claimant, EITC without a qualifying child, KCCATC, child tax credit) | TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#1702 queued (GA: dependent exemption, low income credit, 2026 child credit) | TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#1703 queued (ID: food tax credit, household and dependent care deduction) | TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2242 queued (GA: HB 162 surplus refund) | TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2243 queued (ID: 2022 rebate floor)

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

MaxGhenis and others added 11 commits October 8, 2026 11:03
The federal standard deduction and 17 state formulas read only whether the
tax-unit head is claimed elsewhere, so a joint return where one spouse can be
claimed was taxed differently depending on which spouse was labelled head.
Each formula now applies its jurisdiction's rule for that case (either spouse,
single filers only, per spouse, or only when every filer is claimed), using
two new label-independent helpers. Adds swap-pair YAML cases and a Hypothesis
property test.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
… barred

The New Mexico, Maine and Hawaii renters gates counted filers who are not
claimed elsewhere, so a tax unit with neither a head nor a spouse (252 in
the default dataset) looked like one whose every filer was claimed. A new
helper, every_filer_is_dependent_elsewhere, requires a claimed filer and no
unclaimed one.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ss EITC

- Hawaii's dependent standard deduction uses earned income net of the
  deductible part of self-employment tax, as the N-11 worksheet does.
- New Mexico's medical care credit needs a filer who is both 65 or older
  and not a dependent when a filer is a dependent elsewhere (NMSA 7-2-18.13).
- The federal EITC without a qualifying child requires that no filer can be
  claimed as a dependent (IRC 32(c)(1)(A)(ii)(III), Publication 596), so
  Missouri's working family credit no longer reaches such a couple.
- Hawaii's food/excise credit keeps minor children receiving public support
  (HRS 235-55.85(c)) on a joint return where one spouse can be claimed.
- Comments label the readings the law does not settle, and the property
  test covers the EITC and the food/excise exemption amount.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
… meaning

- The federal and Oregon dependent worksheets use earned income net of the
  deductible part of self-employment tax, as Hawaii's now does.
- Hawaii's food/excise minor-child count excludes children who can be
  claimed by another taxpayer and the filers themselves (Form N-311 line 3).
- claimed_as_dependent_on_another_return documents what it stands for: a
  §151 deduction for the person is allowable to another taxpayer, so a
  person whose would-be claimer files only for a refund is not one
  (Publications 501 and 596); rules on actually being claimed read it too.
- Hawaii's renters comment labels the mixed joint reading as an inference;
  the Hawaii dependent threshold cites HRS 235-2.4(a)(3) on its page.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A filer who can be claimed on another return is treated as having no
dependents (IRC 152(b)(1); on a joint return either spouse counts) and has no
personal exemption (IRC 151(d)(2)); one who is claimed gets no education
credits (25A(g)(3)), student loan interest deduction (221(c)) or recovery
rebate (6428(d)(2), 6428A(d)(2), 6428B(c)(2)). The model read none of these.
Now the child tax credit and credit for other dependents, the under-13 child
and dependent care qualifying person, exemptions_count and its RI, DE, OH, OR,
WI, HI and NM readers, the recovery rebates, the education credits and the
student loan interest deduction apply them symmetrically for joint returns.
Georgia keeps its own counts; the HI, WI and Treasury exemption reforms
follow the corrected count.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…an be claimed as a dependent

A return on which the filer, or on a joint return either spouse, can be
claimed as a dependent has no dependents (IRC 152(b)(1)), and a childless
filer who can be claimed gets no EITC (IRC 32(c)(1)(A)(ii)(III)).

- DC: the Schedule H property tax credit needs a claimant who was not a
  dependent or is 65 or older (D.C. Code 47-1806.06(k)); one claimant per tax
  filing unit, so the other spouse can claim it. The childless EITC keeps the
  IRC 32 bar; the keep child care affordable credit and the child tax credit
  count no child on such a return.
- Georgia: no dependent exemption on such a return (the 2021-2023 personal
  exemption stays); no low income credit when either filer can be claimed
  (O.C.G.A. 48-7A-3); the HB 162 surplus refund excludes a filer claimed for
  2021 unless that filer had earned income (48-7-20.2(a)). The 2026 child
  credit keeps its IRC 24(c) child test.
- Idaho: the food tax credit leaves out a filer who can be claimed and, on
  such a return, the dependents (63-3024A); the household and dependent care
  deduction needs an IRC 21(b)(1) qualifying individual (63-3022D); the 2022
  rebate counts each taxpayer but no dependents on such a return.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…HB 162 refund; add the property test

O.C.G.A. 48-7A-3(a) lets "each resident taxpayer ... who is not claimed or is
not otherwise eligible to be claimed as a dependent" claim the low income
credit and deems each joint spouse a unit "for purposes of such joint return",
so a joint return keeps both spouses' units while one spouse qualifies; such a
return still counts no dependents (IRC 152(b)(1)). The HB 162 refund is
credited to each qualified taxpayer (48-7-20.2(a), (b)), so a joint return
gets the joint amount while one spouse qualifies.

The property test checks swap invariance and monotonicity of the changed DC,
Georgia and Idaho outputs on Hypothesis and seeded couples.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The flag is a tax-unit array and ages are per person; one-return YAML cases
broadcast, but a vectorized simulation with several returns does not. Adds a
two-return YAML case.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MaxGhenis and others added 10 commits October 10, 2026 08:34
…rty tax and KCCATC reforms; fix test fixtures

- Georgia's dependent exemption reform, DC's property tax credit reform (both
  branches) and the DC KCCATC reform's inactive fallback replace the fixed
  formulas; each now keeps the baseline rule for a claimable filer, with
  regression cases. The Schedule H claimant rule moves into
  `dc_ptc_has_eligible_claimant`, shared by the baseline and the reform.
- Idaho food tax credit cases set twelve qualified months (low incomes made the
  household SNAP-eligible, which zeroed every case).
- Schedule H cases put the rent on the spouse who can be the claimant, so they
  hold whether rent is pooled or limited to the claimant's own payments.
- The HB 162 refund documents that the single flag stands in for "was claimed".

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Child and dependent care: childcare expenses do not count on a return with a
  claimable filer unless a child under 13 still qualifies (IRC 21(b)(2)(A)(ii)).
- Tuition and fees deduction: not allowed to a filer who can be claimed (IRC
  222(c)(3)), so the education credit bar no longer makes such a filer eligible.
- Recovery rebates: the Armed Forces exception waives the identification rule
  only, not the exclusion of a spouse who is another taxpayer's dependent.
- Georgia: the contributed refundable credit and SB 520 reforms count the same
  children as ga_ctc_potential through a new ga_ctc_eligible_child.
- Education credits and student loan interest read the claimed input directly,
  since IRC 25A(g)(3) and 221(c) turn on an actual claim.
- One reference per source document; quote IRC 24(h)(4)(A) exactly.
- Tests: mixed-recipient care, tuition deduction, military rebates, Georgia
  refund cap, and the swapped New Mexico rebate case; the property test now
  covers the state readers of the exemption count.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
# Conflicts:
#	policyengine_us/tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/oh/tax/income/exemptions/personal/oh_personal_exemptions_eligible.yaml
#10024 now separates three facts: is claimed, can be claimed, and the would-be
claimant's filing exception.

- IRC 152(b)(1) gates (child tax credit, credit for other dependents, under-13
  care child and its expenses, dependents in exemptions_count, ARPA dependents,
  Ohio dependents, the Hawaii and Wisconsin reforms) read
  head_or_spouse_is_dependent_elsewhere_without_filing_exception, so a filer
  within the Publication 501 exception keeps their dependents.
- Own exemptions, recovery rebates and the tuition deduction read claimability.
- Education credits and student loan interest keep reading the claimed input.
- Tests: the filing exception and a filer who can be claimed but is not.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
#10024's food/excise credit, Act 115 rebate and renters credit took claimable
filers off exemptions_count themselves. exemptions_count now leaves them out
(and, outside the filing exception, the return's dependents), so those credits
read it as it is; the filing-exception cases were one exemption short.

The renters credit also leaves out a dependent who can be claimed by another
taxpayer (Schedule X counts only people who cannot be), as the food/excise
credit already did.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Education credits: a dependent student is not eligible on a return whose
  filer can be claimed outside the filing exception (IRC 25A(f)(1)(A)(iii),
  152(b)(1)); the filer's own eligibility still turns on an actual claim.
- Recovery rebates: no credit when every filer is a dependent of another
  taxpayer (IRC 6428B(a)); the CARES and CAA child prerequisite is a spouse
  with a valid SSN, whether or not that spouse is an eligible individual.
- Child and dependent care: cdcc_qualifying_childcare_expenses holds the
  expense rule, and the single-parent work requirement reform and California's
  expenses read it.
- References: Georgia HB 136 page 3; one entry per recovery rebate statute;
  quote IRC 24(h)(4)(A) exactly in the test comment.
- Tests: dependent students, the two rebate cases, the reform and California
  expenses, and the Hawaii, Wisconsin and Treasury reforms with a claimable
  filer under both labellings.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Education credits: is_barred_from_education_credits_by_dependency holds the
  claimed-filer and dependent-student rules; both eligibility formulas and the
  reconciliation SSN reform's Lifetime Learning Credit read it, so the reform
  no longer turns a barred student's tuition into that credit.
- Child and dependent care: childcare counts when any child under 18 is still a
  qualifying individual, so an incapacitated child aged 13 to 17 keeps it.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Setting meets_eitc_identification_requirements on one person made it an input
for every person, so the other spouse lost their SSN too.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MaxGhenis and others added 2 commits October 11, 2026 12:20
…anch

The federal branch (#10087) now separates whether another taxpayer can claim
a filer (`claimable_as_dependent_on_another_return`) from an actual claim
(`claimed_as_dependent_on_another_return`), and adds the Publication 501
filing exception for the Dependent Taxpayer Test
(`head_or_spouse_is_dependent_elsewhere_without_filing_exception`).

- Rules that a return has no dependents (IRC 152(b)(1)) and the childless
  EITC bar read the filing-exception helper, as the federal formulas do.
- Rules that turn on an actual claim read the claim input: Illinois' 2022
  rebate (sec. 212.1, "who is claimed") and Georgia's HB 162 refund ("who was
  claimed").
- Rules that turn on being claimable read claimability: Georgia's low income
  credit ("claimed or ... eligible to be claimed") and Idaho's food tax
  credit ("can claim you"). DC Schedule H's "was a dependent" reads the
  person-level filing-exception helper.
- New cases for a filer who can be claimed but is not, and for the filing
  exception.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MaxGhenis and others added 8 commits November 13, 2026 04:47
Retain the branch credit readings and the new main entries. Clarify the historical Idaho scope in the invariant documentation.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Distinguish the remaining spouses credit from the three-person filing-exception restoration.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Make the refundable reform tests follow Georgia's child definition. Keep the ordinary refund and liability controls.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Main's #10041 rewrote the note on Colorado's premium-assistance item,
directly above the District of Columbia childless EITC item this branch
adds. Keep main's note and the branch's item.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
… filers

Pool the head's and spouse's rent for the District of Columbia property
tax credit, as D.C. Code 47-1806.06(j)(1) treats a married couple as one
tax filing unit with one claimant. Give the unit the home's tax bill
when an eligible claimant holds a property tax input, and keep each
claimant's own age and the dependent bar in subsection (k).

Exclude an Idaho food tax credit filer in every year only when another
taxpayer claims them, under Idaho Code 63-3024A(4).

Count farm profit and a partner's net earnings as earned income for
Georgia's surplus refund, pin the filing exception for the District's
EITC without a qualifying child, and cite govinfo.gov for the Internal
Revenue Code.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Replace the two Rule 771 captures with the rule's complete official text
for 2022 and from April 6, 2023. Cite govinfo.gov for IRC 24(c) in
Georgia's child credit. Limit the Schedule H register note to the
dependent-claimant question that the item records.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Main applied no dependency test to this credit, so the changelog entry
describes the bar as a change.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
For 36 seeded DC couples nobody can claim, in 2021 and 2025, compare the
property tax credit as drawn with the credit after moving all rent and
property tax to each spouse in turn.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@MaxGhenis MaxGhenis changed the title Apply District of Columbia, Georgia and Idaho rules for a filer who can be claimed as a dependent Apply dependent-filer rules in DC, Georgia and Idaho, set DC's 2026 child credit to $0, credit Georgia ITIN children, require a qualifying individual for Idaho's care deduction and count only filers' Schedule H inputs Nov 14, 2026
MaxGhenis and others added 2 commits November 13, 2026 21:43
The couple's two $10,000 rent inputs give 20% x $20,000 - 5% x $56,200
= $1,190.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add an open item on whether Georgia's child credit reaches the child of
a filer whom another taxpayer can claim, and one on whether a business
loss offsets wages for the HB 162 refund. Capture the text of the
Department of Revenue's Qualifying Child Credit page.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@MaxGhenis

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

DTrim99, here's where each item of your review stands at 1f19639860:

Two merges of main since your review, 31dbe91f3e and 1fbc1c2473, keep every candidate id on main and every id this PR adds, and the head merges into main at a29c73d587 without conflict. Run 43676088399 passed every job at 1f19639860 on that merge. An independent AI review of the changes since 956534cd4d found no P1 and asked for the estimate, the rulespec-us posts above and text fixes to the description. I made each.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

@MaxGhenis
MaxGhenis dismissed DTrim99’s stale review November 15, 2026 14:31

Commits since this review answer the critical item, three items to address and suggestions 2 to 4. The description answers suggestions 6 and 7, and rulespec-us posts answer the fourth item. Suggestion 1 went the other way, and #10659 tracks suggestion 5. My reply above maps each item.

@MaxGhenis
MaxGhenis merged commit 774da47 into main Nov 15, 2026
116 of 124 checks passed
@MaxGhenis

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

US + core hub merge audit, us#10050 at 1f196398600fd07b0237bce919eec6bb6fbc48ba (squash): Apply dependent-filer rules in DC, Georgia and Idaho, set DC's 2026 child credit to $0, credit Georgia ITIN children, require a qualifying individual for Idaho's care deduction and count only filers' Schedule H inputs.

  • Reviews:
    • Four independent reviews ran outside GitHub, two in October and two in November, and DTrim99 reviewed on GitHub between them.
    • The first October review requested changes at 0d2cdb8abe. It ran the changed test files at the head and at the merge base, where 24 YAML cases failed, and found three faults. A claimable student's Idaho care deduction counted a child's daycare that doesn't qualify, giving $11,000 instead of $1,000. The invariant identities ignored the filing exception, and the Georgia child credit kept IRC 24(h)(7)'s identification test for an ITIN child without saying so.
    • The second October review approved 634bdc634a. Its checks for all three faults failed at 0d2cdb8abe and passed at the new head, where 80 cases in six files passed. It listed twelve readings, each with its alternative.
    • DTrim99 requested changes at 423be710ba (review 5813316631), after confirming 36 of 36 checks and 16 hand computations. Its critical item found that Schedule H took each spouse's own property tax input instead of the home's whole bill. Of its four items to address, one found that Idaho's bar on claimable filers followed Form 40 over Code 63-3024A without a candidate. Another found one Georgia candidate's follows label at odds with the code and asked to record readings 4a and 8. A third named four terms that no test pinned. The fourth found the three rulespec-us issues pinned to an October head, and rejected "expired" as a reason to leave HB 162's refund and Idaho's 2022 rebate unqueued. Seven suggestions followed, among them per-payer Schedule H rent, a shared claimant test and CI cost figures.
    • Commits on November 13, ending at 956534cd4d, answered those items. They gave owners the home's whole bill, shared the claimant test between the baseline and the reform, added a case for each unpinned term and restated the Georgia low income readings. They also gave $0 to a dependent filer's child in Georgia (reading 4a), counted each positive earnings source for HB 162 (reading 8) and recorded two Idaho candidates.
    • The first November review requested changes at 956534cd4d. Running households on both trees, it found that Schedule H gave each spouse only the rent that spouse held. A couple whose 69-year-old head held $30,000 of rent, with a spouse of 70 and $80,000 of AGI, fell from $1,425 to $0. It also found that the code, tests and changelog called Idaho's new 2015-2022 bar on claimable filers retained. No test covered the DC EITC's filing exception, the branch conflicted with main, and the description lacked an estimate and current rulespec-us issues.
    • The fix round merged main once and added six commits, ending at 1f19639860. It pooled the couple's rent, kept each claimant's own age and gave the unit the home's bill when an eligible claimant holds a property tax input. It also barred Idaho filers whom another taxpayer claims, in every year, counted farm profit and partnership earnings for HB 162 and added the EITC filing-exception cases. Its last commit recorded readings 4a and 8 as open candidates.
    • The second November review read every change since 956534cd4d and found no P1. Nine mutants it ran at the head each failed their target cases, run 43605812303 passed all 36 jobs, and the head merges into main at 61c743cb61 without conflict. It asked for the estimate, the rulespec-us posts and text fixes to the description. Before merge I posted comments that re-pin [pe-parity] DC1: derive Schedule H claimant and claimable-filer KCCATC, EITC and CDCC readers TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#1701, Ingest CPS Social Security as Social Security retirement benefits, and remove reported logic. #1702 and Assign SS_VAL from ASEC to types other than retirement benefits #1703 to this head and filed Add AGI and high-income tax calibration data #2242 and Michigan Earned Income Tax Credit for Working Families #2243. I also made the text fixes and answered DTrim99's review item by item before dismissing it.
  • Methodology choices for maintainers:
    • Schedule H pools the head's and spouse's rent, as main does: neither D.C. Code 47-1806.06 nor OTR's Schedule H splits a couple's rent by payer. Per-payer rent, which DTrim99 called defensible, would give $0 instead of $1,425 in the case at dc_ptc.yaml line 736. The microdata puts rent and property tax on the household head, so per-payer rent would take the senior schedule from a couple with a head under 70 and a spouse of 70 or older.
    • The unit claims the home's tax bill when an eligible claimant holds a property tax input, as DTrim99's critical item asked, while rent carries no such test. A claimable filer under 65 who holds $6,000 of rent leaves the other spouse a $900 claim (line 819). A claimable filer under 65 who holds the home's $3,000 bill leaves $0 (line 609). One rule for both would change one of those cases.
    • Schedule H counts the head's and spouse's rent and property tax, where main summed every tax unit member's inputs. A tax unit that claims its household head as a dependent therefore draws no credit from that head's rent or tax bill.
    • Idaho's food tax credit bars a filer whom another taxpayer claims, in every year, and keeps it for a filer whom someone could claim but nobody claims. For 2015 to 2022, us-id:grocery-credit-claimability-before-2023 stays open. The former Rule 771 required a "permitted and claimed" exemption, and through 2018 the statute tied the credit to section 151. The 2021 case gives $100 (id_grocery_credit.yaml line 275).
    • Georgia's child credit gives $0 for the child of a filer whom another taxpayer can claim, outside the filing exception, where main gives $250 (ga_ctc.yaml line 149). us-ga:child-credit-dependent-filer-child stays open, and DOR's page addresses neither reading.
    • HB 162 counts each positive source of wages, self-employment profit, farm profit or partnership earnings before any loss from another source. A claimed filer with $1,000 of wages and a $1,000 business loss receives $250, where netting would give $0 (ga_surplus_tax_rebate.yaml line 477). us-ga:surplus-refund-earned-income-loss-offset stays open.
    • Two candidates read state: ruled on main and still do: us-dc:schedule-h-claimable-unclaimed-claimant and us-id:grocery-credit-claimable-spouse. This PR adds three more as state: ruled: us-dc:eitc-joint-dependent-worksheet-omission, us-ga:low-income-credit-claimed-or-eligible-disjunction and us-id:grocery-credit-claimable-unclaimed-filer. rulespec-us's register at 8081f0cc69 holds none of the five, so the parity comments hold the rows that rest on them.
  • Gates checked live at merge:
    • gh pr checks exits 0;
    • the latest Pull request run at the head, 43676088399, passed and tested this head merged into main at a29c73d587;
    • MERGEABLE;
    • not a draft;
    • no reviewer's latest review requests changes;
    • the semantic-overlap guard: since a29c73d587, main has changed no area this PR touches. Between the PR's merge base 7acc38c2ac and main at 6836bd142b, main changed one file this PR touches, source_conflicts/candidates.yaml. Main also changed two District of Columbia files in Count gambling winnings in federal gross income and fix the wagering losses deduction #10070, dc_itemized_deductions.py and its test, and Georgia's LIHEAP files in Add Georgia LIHEAP regular cooling assistance #10746. This PR touches none of them, and main changed no Idaho file. The branch merges into main at 6836bd142b without conflict, and the merged file holds 470 unique ids, main's 464 and this PR's six;
    • the merge pins the head.
  • Impact: we estimate that this branch raises state income tax by $107.2m in 2026 on the default dataset. DC's child tax credit falls from $100.7m to $0 (91 tax units, 55,482 weighted), DC's property tax credit falls by $5.0m, and Idaho income tax rises by $1.5m. Main 7acc38c2ac against 1f19639860.
  • Next:
    • Review Idaho's food tax credit for 2015 to 2018, when the statute granted the credit for each exemption that section 151 permitted.
    • Decide how Schedule H treats rent and property tax that a dependent household head holds.
    • #10659 tracks two gaps in Georgia's low income credit: its units count adult dependents, and it lacks the food-stamp exclusion.
    • Check ga_itemizer_credit_potential's reference to 48-7-29.23 against the itemizer provision.
    • The example in us-ga:surplus-refund-earned-income-loss-offset gives $600 of 2021 Georgia tax to a filer whose wages and business loss net to zero. A follow-up can name the other income, such as interest, as reading 8 of the description does.
    • Six source captures hold excerpts by section rather than whole pages: the D-40 worksheet, Schedule H for 2021 and 2025, Form 40 page 2, its instructions and Publication 596. A follow-up can replace them before a register entry pins them.
  • Axiom: [pe-parity] DC1: derive Schedule H claimant and claimable-filer KCCATC, EITC and CDCC readers TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#1701, Ingest CPS Social Security as Social Security retirement benefits, and remove reported logic. #1702 and Assign SS_VAL from ASEC to types other than retirement benefits #1703 queued, each with a comment at 1f19639860 that re-pins it and gives this head's rows. The Add Washington state to modelled_policies.yaml #1701 comment also asks the issue to dispatch DC's child credit, $0 from 2026. Add AGI and high-income tax calibration data #2242 queues Georgia's HB 162 refund under O.C.G.A. 48-7-20.2, and Michigan Earned Income Tax Credit for Working Families #2243 queues Idaho's 2022 rebate under Idaho Code 63-3024B(3), each with companion rows from this PR's YAML. The signed encoder can't run either new issue yet: the corpus release that rulespec-us pins carries neither text, though later corpus scopes hold both.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

@MaxGhenis
MaxGhenis deleted the claimable-filer-dc-ga-id branch November 15, 2026 14:31
MaxGhenis added a commit that referenced this pull request Nov 15, 2026
Both #10050 and this branch append cases to the DC Keep Child Care
Affordable credit and Schedule H credit tests. This merge keeps main's
2025 cases and this branch's 2026 cases.

In test_state_uprating_rounding.py, #10324 rewrote the Arkansas bracket
test at the line where this branch adds its Vermont and Wisconsin
helpers. This merge keeps main's Arkansas test and its half-down helper
beside this branch's helpers and tests.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants