Skip to content

Count Minnesota's listed income for the property tax refund and only the claimant's and spouse's for the renter's credit - #11172

Merged
DTrim99 merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
mn-property-tax-refund-renters-credit-income
Nov 20, 2026
Merged

DTrim99 merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
mn-property-tax-refund-renters-credit-income

Conversation

@DTrim99

@DTrim99 DTrim99 commented Nov 19, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Part of #10812 (state credit income audit).

What was wrong

Homestead Credit Refund (Form M1PR). mn_homestead_credit_refund_household_income started from federal AGI and added only nontaxable Social Security and retirement contributions. Minn. Stat. 290A.03, subd. 3(a)(2) (HTML, no pages) adds more amounts "to the extent not included in clause (1)" (federal AGI). The model left out SSI, cash public assistance, workers' compensation, government interest, retirement account distributions outside AGI, alimony outside AGI and the HSA deduction. The retirement subtraction limit (retirement_subtraction/limit.yaml) was frozen at $7,000 ($14,000 joint) from 2024, while subd. 3(d)(2) ties it to the federal IRA deductible amount, which is $7,500 in 2026.

Renter's credit (Schedule M1RENT). mn_renters_credit_household_agi summed AGI over the whole SPM unit, so a roommate's or other adult's income counted as the renter's. Minn. Stat. 290.0693, subd. 1(g) takes "household" from 290A.03, subd. 4: "a claimant and an individual related to the claimant as the claimant's spouse who are domiciled in the same homestead". 290.0693, subd. 7: "If a homestead is occupied by two or more renters who are not married to each other ... separate claims shall be filed by each renter. The income of each renter shall be each renter's household income". The 2025 Schedule M1RENT instructions, page 3, "Lived with a roommate": "Include only your income when filing for the credit."

What changes

Homestead Credit Refund household income

A new list, gov.states.mn.tax.property.homestead_credit_refund.income_additions, holds the amounts added to federal AGI. It cites 290A.03, subd. 3(a)(2) and the 2025 Form M1PR instructions, pages 7-8:

  • ssi: subd. 3(a)(2)(v), "Supplemental Security Income". Line 4 (page 7): "Include nontaxable payments you received from the Minnesota Family Investment Program (MFIP), Minnesota Supplemental Aid (MSA), Supplemental Security Income (SSI), General Assistance (GA)".
  • general_assistance, mn_msa_person and tanf (MFIP in Minnesota, cash portion): subd. 3(a)(2)(iv), "cash public assistance and relief", and line 4 above. The review doesn't name MSA, but line 4 lists it with GA and MFIP and the model computes it, so I included it.
  • workers_compensation: subd. 3(a)(2)(vii). Line 6 (page 8) says "to the extent not used for medical expenses". The model can't split that out, so all of it counts.
  • tax_exempt_interest_income: subd. 3(a)(2)(vi), "interest received from the federal or a state government or any instrumentality or political subdivision thereof"; line 6, "Federally nontaxed interest and mutual fund dividends".
  • tax_exempt_retirement_distributions: subd. 3(a)(2)(xii), "to the extent not included in federal adjusted gross income, distributions received by the claimant or spouse from a traditional or Roth style retirement account or plan"; line 6, "Distributions from a ROTH or traditional IRA not included on line 1".
  • health_savings_account_ald: subd. 3(a)(2)(xv), "the amount of deduction allowed under section 220 or 223"; line 6, "Health savings account and Archer MSA deductions". The model has no Archer MSA deduction.

The formula sums the list with tax_unit_non_dep_add. Person amounts count for the head and spouse only (subd. 5: "other than income of a dependent"). tanf is an SPM-unit amount, so it counts as the tax unit's per-person share, as in Wisconsin's homestead credit.

Alimony is computed in the formula as alimony_income − taxable_alimony_income, the AZ/ND pattern. Subd. 3(a)(2)(xiv): "alimony received to the extent not included in the recipient's income"; line 6, "Alimony received to the extent not included in adjusted gross income". Pre-2019 alimony is already in AGI and counts once.

Retirement base amount. Subd. 3(d)(2): "'retirement base amount' means the deductible amount for the taxable year for the claimant and spouse under section 219(b)(5)(A) of the Internal Revenue Code, adjusted for inflation as provided in section 219(b)(5)(C)". The formula multiplies gov.irs.gross_income.retirement_contributions.limit.ira by the number of filers in the tax unit (head and spouse). That parameter holds the 219(b)(5)(A) amount: $7,000 for 2024-2025, $7,500 for 2026 (IRS Notice 2025-67, page 4), uprated after that. For 2024-2025 this gives the same $7,000 / $14,000 as before, matching the 2025 M1PR line 10 instructions on page 9. retirement_subtraction/limit.yaml is removed; nothing else read it.

Renter's credit household AGI

mn_renters_credit_household_agi is now a tax-unit variable. It is the filer's federal AGI (Schedule M1RENT line 1), which already leaves out dependents' income, plus a separate filer's spouse's AGI (line 2, page 4). The spouse's AGI used to be added in mn_renters_credit_household_income, which now reads the new variable and keeps the age, disability and dependent subtractions. mn_renters_credit_qualifying_crp is unchanged.

Who is affected

  • Homestead Credit Refund. Minnesota homeowners whose head or spouse receives SSI, MSA, General Assistance, MFIP, workers' compensation, tax-exempt interest, Roth or other nontaxable retirement distributions, or alimony under a post-2018 divorce, or who take the HSA deduction. Their household income rises, so their refund falls or ends. From 2026, claimants who contribute more than $7,000 ($14,000 joint) to retirement accounts see household income fall by up to $500 ($1,000 joint), so their refund rises. The refund is paid outside the income tax (state_property_tax_refunds), so Minnesota income tax doesn't change.
  • Renter's credit. Minnesota renters who share an SPM unit with another adult who files their own return: a roommate, an unmarried partner, or an adult relative who isn't their dependent. Their household income falls to their own, so their credit rises or begins. The credit is refundable (mn/tax/income/credits/refundable.yaml), so their Minnesota income tax falls. In the rare case where the other adult had negative AGI, household income rises instead.

Tests

Moved from #10812:

  • mn_homestead_credit_refund_household_income.yaml: all eight cases (SSI, General Assistance, workers' compensation, nontaxed interest, Roth IRA distribution, post-2018 alimony, HSA deduction, 2026 retirement base amount). Expected values are unchanged. Main gave 6,800, 10,000, 30,000, 30,000, 30,000, 20,000, 48,000 and 53,000.
  • mn_renters_credit_household_income.yaml: the roommate case replaces "Case 3, other adult household income counts", as the review asked. It expects [4_800, 60_000]; main gave [64_800, 70_000].

Added:

  • Household income:

    • MSA: 9,000 + 1,200 − 5,200 = 5,000.
    • An MFIP grant for a parent and child: 5,000 + 6,000 − 7,280 = 3,720.
    • Pre-2019 alimony counted once: 26,000.
    • The 2026 subtraction stopping at $7,500 with $10,000 of Roth 401(k) deferrals: 52,500.
    • The 2025 subtraction still stopping at $7,000: 53,000.
    • A 2026 joint couple stopping at $15,000: 80,000 − 15,000 = 65,000.
  • mn_homestead_credit_refund.yaml, end to end: a 70-year-old homeowner with a $12,000 pension, $3,000 of SSI and $2,000 of property tax. Household income is 9,800 and the refund is round((2,000 − 0.014 × 9,800) × 0.83) = 1,546. On main, household income is 6,800 and the refund is 1,587.

  • mn_renters_credit_household_agi.yaml:

    • Roommates in one SPM unit: [25_000, 45_000] (main: 70,000 for the SPM unit).
    • A separate filer with AGI of 40,000: 80,000.
  • mn_renters_credit.yaml, end to end: roommates aged 66 and 40 with $10,000 and $60,000 of wages and $9,000 of rent each. The credits are [1_408, 198]:

    • Person 1: round((1,530 − 48) × 0.95) = 1,408.
    • Person 2: (1,530 − 1,200) × 0.60 = 198.

    On main, with household income [64_800, 70_000], the credits are [129, 65].

Changed: only the replaced Case 3 above. The existing couple case in mn_renters_credit_household_agi.yaml still gives 24,000 with the tax-unit variable.

Not in this PR

Other Minnesota gaps from the #10812 audit:

  • Homestead Credit Refund:
    • nontaxable pensions and annuities (subd. 3(a)(2)(v) and 3(b)(2) depend on who funded them, which tax_exempt_pension_income doesn't record);
    • tax-exempt disability income and sick pay;
    • nontaxable strike benefits;
    • nontaxable scholarships;
    • the educator expense deduction add-back;
    • employer dependent care benefits and other pre-tax account contributions;
    • the foreign earned income exclusion;
    • co-occupant income (290A.05);
    • survivor benefits (the statute and the instructions read differently);
    • railroad retirement benefits (open PR Count railroad benefits in state tax worksheets, income tests and limits as each state's law does #10722);
    • veterans' pensions, loss carryforwards and the other line 6 items with no input.
  • Renter's credit: the SEIU stipend subtraction (no input) and part-year residency (not modeled).
  • K-12 education credit: the 2021-2022 income definition (former subd. 2a) added nontaxable income to AGI; the model uses AGI in every year.
  • Marriage credit: earned income leaves out taxable retirement account distributions. Military retired pay and taxable Social Security each have two readings.

axiom: needed (Minn. Stat. 290A.03, subd. 3 and 290.0693, subd. 1 aren't encoded here; a signed encoder run needs separate approval)

Tested on Modal: run w1-mn-a, 246/246 passed. That covers 243 YAML files (the Minnesota test folder, every partner test and state_property_tax_refunds.yaml) and 3 Python files (the source-conflict guard, the dependents' above-the-line deduction invariants and the household/SPM resource parity tests).

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

The Homestead Credit Refund now adds the amounts Minn. Stat. 290A.03,
subd. 3(a)(2) counts beyond federal AGI: SSI, Minnesota Supplemental Aid,
General Assistance, MFIP, workers' compensation, tax-exempt interest,
nontaxable retirement account distributions, alimony not in AGI and the
HSA deduction. Its retirement base amount follows the federal IRA
deductible amount for the claimant and spouse (subd. 3(d)(2)), so it is
$7,500 per filer from 2026 instead of a frozen $7,000.

The renter's credit counts only the claimant's and spouse's AGI
(290.0693, subd. 1(g) and 7), not the AGI of other adults in the SPM unit.

Moves the Minnesota cases from the #10812 audit into the real test files.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@DTrim99
DTrim99 requested a review from hua7450 November 19, 2026 23:41

@hua7450 hua7450 left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Thanks, David. Every addition matches Minn. Stat. 290A.03, subd. 3, with no double counting against AGI (the HSA deduction is added back once). The renter's credit correctly counts the claimant and spouse only (290.0693, subd. 1(g)-(i) and 7). The retirement subtraction is still computed; only the frozen $7,000 / $14,000 table goes, replaced by the federal IRA limit, and nothing else reads the deleted parameter. No existing test input changed. Approving.

Optional:

  • Four listed additions with ready variables. 290A.03, subd. 3(a)(2) and M1PR line 6 also list educator expenses, strike benefits, disability benefits and the foreign earned income exclusion. educator_expense_ald, strike_benefits_excluded_from_gross_income, tax_exempt_disability_benefits and foreign_earned_income_exclusion exist; each is one list line, or a sentence on why it waits.
  • Two rules without a failing test. Every new case has one tax unit and no dependent income, so nothing pins "head and spouse only" for the new list or the per-person tanf share. One case each would do (a dependent with ssi; an SPM unit with two tax units and tanf).
  • Separated spouse (follow-up, same on main). A filer who is SEPARATE through is_separated still gets a spouse AGI equal to their own added in both credits. The statute counts only a spouse "domiciled in the same homestead".
  • Follow-up: the 2025 one-time increase. The 2025 M1PR adds line 17a, a 14.88% increase to the refund. It is not modeled, and new Case 9 pins 1,546 without it (1,776 with it). That belongs in its own PR.
  • Smaller items. Nondeductible alimony paid (subd. 3(b)(8), M1PR line 11) is not subtracted; the workers' compensation difference between statute and instructions is not in source_conflicts/candidates.yaml; and one m1rent-25.pdf reference has no #page=.

@DTrim99
DTrim99 merged commit 0bbc1ab into main Nov 20, 2026
37 checks passed
@DTrim99
DTrim99 deleted the mn-property-tax-refund-renters-credit-income branch November 20, 2026 15:34
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants