Repository navigation
Add New Mexico's Puente Health premium assistance - #11167
Conversation
hua7450
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Thanks, David. Puente Health checks out against 8.401.2.11 NMAC, Addendum 2 to the PY2026 manual and the FINAL PY2027 manual: Section 71302 members at or below 100% FPL in 2026, Section 71301 or 71302 members at or below 400% in 2027, DACA and undocumented members excluded, and Medicaid, CHIP, employer offers and Medicare excluded through the federal list. Both years are adopted. The benchmark reuses the existing helper, no benchmark premium is counted twice, and twelve amount cases and both integration scenarios match by hand. Three fixes before I approve.
Before merge
- Member eligibility never checks that the person is outside the federal credit. In
nm_puente_health_member_eligible.py(lines 56-95), the exclusion holds only through the derived path. Withpays_aca_premium: truesupplied, a 2027 single TPS holder at 250% FPL getsaca_ptc4,242.78 +nm_premium_assistance2,657.34 + Puente 6,900.12 = 13,800.25 on a $7,698.12 plan; without the flag the total is 6,900.12. Adding& ~person("is_aca_ptc_eligible", period)makes the program's premise explicit (no circular dependency), with one case for it. - A mixed-status household has the Table 1 share subtracted twice. Base assistance and Puente each subtract the share of the whole household's income. A 2027 LPR and TPS couple at 390% FPL gets base 819.85 + Puente 819.85 and pays 16.3% of income, against Table 1's 8.15%: about $6,878 a year less assistance. The documentation and the PR body size this as "2% of income at 250% FPL", but it reaches 8.5% at 400%. The PY2027 manual (p. 4) describes "capping the SLCSP cost as a percentage of household income", which points to one household contribution. Please either subtract the share once across the two programs, or keep the split with the range stated correctly and a mixed-status case that pins the household total.
- One New Mexico ratio.
nm_puente_health_fpl_ratioinnm_puente_health_eligible.py(lines 4-21) is a helper function called at three sites. With the shared NM ratio variable requested on 10328, New Mexico would have two definitions. Please make it one guarded TaxUnit variable in whichever PR merges first and read it in the other. The gross-up block innm_puente_health_premium_assistance.py(lines 54-60) is also a line-for-line copy ofnm_premium_assistance.py(lines 51-57), which 10328 edits, so the two can drift.
Optional
- A reading to list: the 10% increase at 200% to 400% FPL in 2027. The PY2027 manual (p. 8) says the under-200% calculation "also applies to those in the Puente Health Program", with no income limit on that sentence. The code applies the increase only under 200%, which is defensible (p. 5: "For all other eligible New Mexico Premium Assistance enrollees, the actual price of the SLCSP will be used"), but it is not among the eight listed readings. Under the literal reading integration Scenario 1 would be $7,669.94, not $6,900.12. Worth listing, and confirming with HCA or BeWell if you can.
- Take-up.
takes_up_nm_puente_health_if_eligibleis a formula returningtakes_up_aca_if_eligible, unlike the plain-input siblings. With ACA take-up false at 150% FPL, base assistance still counts 1,799.23 while Puente counts 0. Puente's behavior is the better one; aligning the state premium programs could be one follow-up (11169 uses the same pattern). - Net-premium cap. Puente caps at the selected plan and base assistance does not, so at 150% FPL the base path pays 110% of the benchmark plan. The base comment "no plan-selection input" is now stale.
programs.yaml. Puente appears only in a YAML comment, which the metadata API does not serve. A one-sentencenotes:or its own entry (asco_omnisaludhas) would register it.- Amendment PDF.
08.401.0002_amended.pdfis cited as a reprint of the rule in force, but its numbering differs (8.401.2.11(C)(2) is (C)(1)(b) there). Say what the PDF is, or cite the in-force page alone. - Tests. A few same-class duplicates (member-eligible Case 1; eligible Case 3; amount Cases 3, 9 and 10), and the integration file has two single-adult scenarios only.
Follow-up outside this PR. The federal gov.aca.ineligible_immigration_statuses list omits CONDITIONAL_ENTRANT for 2027, although Section 71301 bars it too. Puente would follow a fix automatically.
Puente Health pays state premium assistance on BeWell to lawfully present non-citizens who lost the federal premium tax credit under Public Law 119-21: those under 100% of the poverty line (Section 71302) in 2026, and those at or below 400% (Sections 71301 and 71302) in 2027. It pays the members' benchmark, increased by 10% below 200% of the poverty line, minus the Table 1 share of income, capped at the selected plan's premium. The take-up-gated amount joins the household health benefit lists. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…h, charge mixed-status households one share, share the NM ratio - Puente member eligibility now excludes people eligible for the federal premium tax credit. - Puente premium assistance subtracts only the part of the expected share that base NM premium assistance leaves, so mixed-status households pay one share in total. - New TaxUnit variable nm_premium_assistance_fpl_ratio replaces the duplicated FPL-ratio helper at all three sites, with its own tests. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
0ba9232 to
13f56d4
Compare
|
Thanks, Ziming. Fixed in 13f56d4, rebased on main. Fixed (your "Before merge" items)
I updated the PR body: readings 5 and 6, the member list, the #10328 note and the test counts. Skipped (optional, not in this round): listing the literal reading of the 10% increase at 200-400% FPL, and the other optional items. Verification: the NM premium assistance and Puente tests pass locally after the rebase (156/156), as do the code-health reference and source-conflict checks. An independent check confirmed all three items by hand, including the no-base, partial and full-absorption cases, and that no expected value was fitted to model output. |
hua7450
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Thanks, David. All three fixes check out.
- Outside the federal credit. Membership now requires
~is_aca_ptc_eligible, which matches 8.401.2.11(C)(2) NMAC ("has become ineligible for the federal Premium Tax Credit"), with no cycle; member Case 16 pins the supplied-flag case. - One household share. Base assistance and Puente together now bring the household down to one Table 1 share in every regime: no base assistance, partial or full absorption, the plan cap and the zero floor. I get your Scenario 3 (8,517.98) and Case 19 (5,121.73) by hand, and it follows the PY2027 manual's p. 4 cap ("capping the SLCSP cost as a percentage of household income").
- One NM ratio.
nm_premium_assistance_fpl_ratioreplaces the helper at all three sites. Its float32 storage never moves a ratio across the 100%, 200% or 400% limits. 10328 should read it once this merges.
No existing case changed its inputs. Approving.
Optional:
- Case 14. It reaches the no-base-assistance regime only because the test supplies
aca_magiwhile the head's own income is $0, which makes him Medicaid-eligible and then barred from the credit by the work requirement. With consistent income, an LPR at 250% FPL keeps the credit. Either say that in the comment or force the regime with an explicit input such asis_aca_eshi_eligible. - Documentation. "One Table 1 share" is a reading of the manual's p. 4 cap (both NMAC formulas carry the full income term and don't address mixed households). The PR body says so; the variable's documentation states it as the rule.
- Drift. Puente re-derives base assistance's gross-up and federal remainder instead of reading them, so the two can drift once 10328 changes the base program.
- From the first round: the 10% increase reading at 200-400% FPL, the take-up flag, the base program's plan cap, the
programs.yamlentry and the amendment PDF title.
Fixes #9265
What this adds
New Mexico's Puente Health program pays state premium assistance on BeWell to lawfully present non-citizens who lost the federal premium tax credit under Public Law 119-21. The model already removes their federal credit (
below_fpl_immigration_exception_in_effectis false from 2026, andineligible_immigration_statusesadds TPS, refugees, asylees, withholding of deportation and parole of a year or more from 2027). Until now it gave them nothing from New Mexico either.Who qualifies (8.401.2.11(C) NMAC):
What they get: the benchmark (SLCSP) for the Puente Health members, increased by 10% below the base program's gross-up limit, minus the Table 1 share of household income, floored at zero and capped at the premium of the plan they select ("A consumer's net premium cannot be lower than $0").
New parameters (
gov.states.nm.hca.premium_assistance.puente):in_effectfpl_limitineligible_immigration_statusesThe gross-up (
benchmark_gross_up.*) and Table 1 (nm_premium_assistance_target_contribution_percentage) are the base program's, read as they are; this PR doesn't change them.Who counts as a Puente Health member
nm_puente_health_member_eligiblereads the same inputs the federal credit uses for the two sections, so the group is exactly the people the model's federal credit excludes under them:gov.aca.ineligible_immigration_statusesbars. Before 2027 that list holds only DACA and undocumented status, so the group is empty in 2026. If the federal list changes (for example, ifCONDITIONAL_ENTRANTis added: Section 71301 limits the credit to LPRs, Cuban/Haitian entrants and COFA migrants, but the list doesn't name conditional entrants), Puente Health follows it.aca_ptc_below_fpl_immigration_exceptioncovered (income under 100% FPL, a credit-eligible status, Medicaid-ineligible because of that status), once that exception is no longer in effect.is_aca_ptc_eligible), so supplyingpays_aca_premiumcannot pay both.gov.aca.ineligible_coverage(Medicaid, CHIP, employer coverage and so on).Readings I had to choose
slcsp,aca_ptc_slcsp,pays_aca_premiumandselected_marketplace_plan_premium_proxyall leave them out.nm_puente_health_benchmark_premiumprices them with the federalbenchmark_premiumhelper (age-curve quotes, the three oldest children charged).nm_puente_health_plan_premiumfollows the plan-selection inputs: a silver plan at the members' benchmark timesselected_marketplace_plan_benchmark_ratio; a bronze plan at the members' benchmark times the rating area's bronze-to-silver age-0 price, which is exact in New Mexico because both metal levels use the default age curve. At the default selection (silver, ratio 1.0) the cap is the benchmark, so the 10% increase only shows for a pricier silver plan. The amount itself isn't gated on take-up; theassigned_*version is.nm_premium_assistance_fpl_ratio, one guarded TaxUnit variable (the exact ratiomax_(aca_magi, 0)/aca_fpgdivided in float64, infinite when there is no guideline), decides the 100% and 400% limits and the under-200% increase. 8.401.2.7(G) NMAC defines the FPL as the HHS level "for the applicable coverage year for the health insurance exchange", the prior-year guidelineaca_fpgholds, and 8.401.2.11(D)(1)(a) measures income as in 45 CFR 155.305(f).in_effectends after 2027, as the base program's does. Keeping it on would carry the PY2027 rules forward.Not modeled: State Out-of-Pocket Assistance (the Turquoise cost-sharing variants), QSEHRA offsets and the ICHRA exclusion, and the Medicaid Transition Premium Relief program. The Native American schedule (#9266) is on hold.
How it's wired
nm_puente_health_premium_assistanceis the amount before take-up, for the ACA calculator.assigned_nm_puente_health_premium_assistancemultiplies it bytakes_up_nm_puente_health_if_eligible, which defaults totakes_up_aca_if_eligible: Puente Health pays only for plans bought on BeWell.healthcare_benefit_valueandgov.household.household_health_benefits, right afterassigned_nm_premium_assistance.programs.yaml: the NM entry's note now lists Puente Health as modeled. Its status stays partial until the Native American pieces land.Effect on existing households: only New Mexico tax units with a Puente Health member change. They gain a health benefit in 2026 (Section 71302 group) and 2027 (both groups). Nothing else reads the new variables.
The Puente Health parameters, variables and tests are in their own
puente/folders, plus one shared file:nm_premium_assistance_fpl_ratio(and its test) inpremium_assistance/, the TaxUnit ratio requested on #10328 (NM premium assistance exact ratio). Whichever of the two PRs merges second should read that variable rather than define its own; #10328 currently computes the same ratio inline in three files. The Puente gross-up block still repeats the one innm_premium_assistance.py, because sharing it would mean editing a file #10328 changes.Tests
New files under
tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/nm/hca/premium_assistance/puente/:nm_puente_health_member_eligible.yaml(16 cases; Case 16, added after review, is a federal-credit-eligible TPS holder withpays_aca_premiumsupplied): each Section 71301 status and every other status, in one vectorized case; the 2026 and 2027 Section 71302 group, just under and exactly at 100% FPL; past the five-year bar; 2025, before the repeal; and the tax-family, separate-return, other-coverage and out-of-state exclusions.nm_puente_health_eligible.yaml(11): exactly 400% and one dollar above it, 400.5% (which truncation reads as 4.00), $0 income, the 2026 limit on both sides of 100%, 2025 and 2028, and no member.nm_puente_health_premium_assistance.yaml(19; Case 19, added after review, is a mixed-status household where base NMPA partly absorbs the share): the audit's nine cases, recomputed from the sources (all nine hold); the 1.1 increase just under and exactly at 200%; a bronze cap; a mixed-status couple; out of state; 2028; negative income; and the zero floor.nm_puente_health_benchmark_premium.yaml(3): the three-oldest-children rule, a mixed couple, and no member.assigned_nm_puente_health_premium_assistance.yaml(4): take-up, and the assigned amount reachinghousehold_health_benefits.integration.yaml(3): fully derived 2027 TPS and 2026 LPR households in Bernalillo County, throughhealthcare_benefit_value, and (after review) the 390% FPL LPR and TPS couple paying the share once.Also new:
tests/policy/baseline/gov/states/nm/hca/premium_assistance/nm_premium_assistance_fpl_ratio.yaml(3).No existing expected value changed.
Tested on Modal: run
s4-nm-b, 334/334 passed. The run covered the Puente Health and New Mexico premium assistance YAML files, every household and partner YAML file, the other YAML files that readhealthcare_benefit_valueorhousehold_health_benefits, andtest_source_conflicts.pyandtest_programs_registry.py. No partner test changed.axiom: needed
🤖 Generated with Claude Code