Skip to content

Update Cascade Care Savings to the 2027 amounts, with the 200% FPL split - #11152

Merged
hua7450 merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
wa-cascade-care-savings-2027
Nov 20, 2026
Merged

hua7450 merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
wa-cascade-care-savings-2027

Conversation

@DTrim99

@DTrim99 DTrim99 commented Nov 19, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

What changes

Washington's Cascade Care Savings amounts change for plan year 2027:

Members 2026 2027 Source
With federal subsidies, income up to 200% FPL $55 PMPM $35 PMPM WAHBE memo of 2026-10-01, p.1; Final PY 2027 policy §5(1)(b), p.6
With federal subsidies, income above 200% FPL (to 250%) $55 PMPM $20 PMPM Same
Without federal subsidies, income up to 250% FPL $250 PMPM $185 PMPM Memo p.1; policy §5(1)(b), p.6

The 250% income limit stays the same (policy §4(1)(c), p.3), and so does the household cap (§5(1)(d), p.7). The model has no end date for the program, so 2028 onward carries the 2027 amounts forward. The in_effect comment now records the funding risk: PY2027 ends the biennium, and WAHBE "has not yet secured funding for PY 2028" (memo p.3).

How the model does it:

  • amount/with_federal_subsidy is now a two-band single_amount scale on the income-to-poverty-line ratio. Its thresholds are -inf and 2. Its amounts are 55/55 from 2026 and 35/20 from 2027. The formula reads it with calc(ratio, right=True).
  • amount/without_federal_subsidy: 185 from 2027-01-01 (was 250).
  • New TaxUnit variable wa_cascade_care_savings_fpl_ratio (YEAR, /1, WA only): max_(aca_magi, 0).astype(np.float64) / aca_fpg, without truncation. Where aca_fpg is 0, it divides by 1 and returns an infinite ratio, as aca_magi_fraction does, which fails the income limit. The eligibility gate from Decide Washington Cascade Care Savings eligibility on the exact FPL ratio #10314 now reads this variable instead of its inline ratio, and the member amount reads it for the split. The 250% limit and the 200% split are therefore decided on the same ratio.
  • fpl_limit and in_effect get their 2027 references (policy §4(1)(c), p.3; policy §2, p.1; memo p.3). Their values don't change.
  • The documentation strings in wa_cascade_care_savings.py and wa_cascade_care_savings_member_amount.py gave only the $55 and $250 amounts. They now give both years.

Readings

Incomes above 200% but below 201% of FPL. The policy sets "one amount for customers up to 200% FPL and one amount for customers 201 – 250% FPL" (§5(1)(b)), and the memo has the same bands. Neither says which amount applies above 200% but below 201%. On 2026-11-18 the project lead ruled that this is decided on the exact ratio: a household at or below 2.00 gets $35, and any ratio above 2.00 gets $20. The parameter comment records the ruling. A whole-percent reading would have paid $35 up to 200.99%. Two cases pin the ruling at 200.5%: Case 29 in wa_cascade_care_savings.yaml and Case 11 in wa_cascade_care_savings_member_amount.yaml.

The scale's edges. I read SingleAmountTaxScale.calc in the installed policyengine-core (3.33.2) and checked that it is identical in the locked 3.36.0. It calls numpy.digitize(base, [-inf] + thresholds + [inf], right=right) and pads the amounts with a 0 at each end. With right=True, a ratio equal to a threshold falls in the band below it. So 2.00 gets $35 and 2.000001 gets $20. The first threshold is -inf because a threshold of 0 would send a ratio of exactly 0 into the padding cell and pay $0. Member Case 13 (zero income, $35) tests this.

Precision. The ratio is divided in float64 but stored as float32, like every float variable. For a whole-dollar guideline, the smallest float32 income above 2.00 or 2.50 times the guideline still rounds to a stored ratio above the threshold, so storing it as float32 doesn't move the limit or the split. The one-cent cases below check this.

Not in this PR: widening Group 3 to the lawfully present people who lose the federal credit in 2027 (audit §3.3 (6)), which is a later step. Plan choice isn't modeled, so the new Bronze eligibility and the carrier conditions (§4(2)) have no effect on the model.

Tests

Changed expected values (both have the same inputs: one Group 1 member at 140% FPL, SLCSP $6,000, credit $5,000, 2027):

  • integration.yaml Scenario 9: 660 → 420. The base is 12 × $35 = 420, under the cap of 6,000 − 5,000 = 1,000.
  • wa_cascade_care_savings.yaml Case 16: 660 → 420, for the same reason.

Added (supplied aca_magi and aca_fpg of $10,000 unless noted):

  • wa_cascade_care_savings_fpl_ratio.yaml (new, 9 cases): 140%; exactly 200%; 200.5% (exact ratio 2.005, truncated fraction 2.00); 250.005%; negative income (0); guidelines derived from the model for 2026 ($15,650 → 2.5) and 2027 ($15,960 → 2.0); a zero guideline (tax unit ineligible, amount 0); a household outside Washington (0).
  • wa_cascade_care_savings_member_amount.yaml, Cases 8–20. For 2027, Group 1 gets 420 at 140%, 420 at exactly 200%, 240 one cent above 200%, 240 at 200.5%, 240 at 201% and 420 at zero income. Group 3 gets 2,220 at 150% and 240%. In a mixed household at 220%, the amounts are 240 / 2,220 / 0, and a Group 2 member gets 2,220 beside a Group 1 member's 240. For 2026, Group 1 still gets 660 at exactly 200%, one cent above and 240%.
  • wa_cascade_care_savings.yaml, Cases 26–37. For 2027: 300 when the cap binds; 420 at exactly 200%; 240 one cent above it, at 200.5% and at 201%. Two Group 1 members and one Group 3 member get 12 × (2 × 35 + 185) = 3,060 at 180% and 12 × (2 × 20 + 185) = 2,700 at 220%. Exactly 250% is eligible for 240, and 250.005% gets 0. Group 3 gets 2,220 at 150% and 240%. For 2026, Group 1 at 240% still gets 660.
  • wa_cascade_care_savings_eligible.yaml, Cases 11–12: 2027 at the model's 2026 guideline. $39,900 (exactly 250%) is eligible. $39,900.01 is ineligible, although the truncated fraction is 2.50.

I recomputed every audit §3.4 value from the memo and the policy, and all of them agree. The audit's Case 8 has the same inputs as the updated Case 16, so I didn't add it twice. Its Case 15 (refugee) belongs to the Group 3 change.

Tested on Modal: run s2-wa-a, 159/159 passed (the eight YAML files: the six Cascade Care Savings files, healthcare_benefit_value.yaml and household_health_benefits.yaml), plus 80/80 in test_reference_urls.py, test_parameter_yaml_keys.py and test_claimable_filer_ptc_invariants.py. In that run, test_source_conflicts.py failed only because the harness mounts policyengine_us/ without the repo-root source_conflicts/ folder (10 FileNotFoundErrors), plus one case whose tokenizer behaviour differs on the image's Python 3.11. Run s2-wa-b, with source_conflicts/ mounted on Python 3.13: 251/251 passed.

axiom: needed

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

From plan year 2027, Washington pays $35 a month per member with federal
subsidies up to 200% of the federal poverty line and $20 above it, and
$185 without federal subsidies (WAHBE memo of 2026-10-01, p.1; Final PY
2027 policy Section 5(1)(b)). The with-subsidy amount becomes a two-band
scale on the income-to-poverty-line ratio. A new tax-unit variable holds
that exact ratio, and both the 250% income limit and the 200% split read
it. Per the project lead's 2026-11-18 ruling, a ratio at or below 2.00
gets $35 and any ratio above 2.00 gets $20.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@codecov

codecov Bot commented Nov 19, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Codecov Report

✅ All modified and coverable lines are covered by tests.
✅ Project coverage is 100.00%. Comparing base (8999568) to head (ab9e8d9).
⚠️ Report is 238 commits behind head on main.

Additional details and impacted files
@@            Coverage Diff            @@
##              main    #11152   +/-   ##
=========================================
  Coverage   100.00%   100.00%           
=========================================
  Files            1         4    +3     
  Lines           24        74   +50     
=========================================
+ Hits            24        74   +50     
Flag Coverage Δ
unittests 100.00% <100.00%> (ø)

Flags with carried forward coverage won't be shown. Click here to find out more.

☔ View full report in Codecov by Harness.
📢 Have feedback on the report? Share it here.

🚀 New features to boost your workflow:
  • ❄️ Test Analytics: Detect flaky tests, report on failures, and find test suite problems.

@hua7450 hua7450 left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Thanks, David. The Washington 2027 amounts check out: $35 a month per member with federal subsidies up to 200% FPL, $20 above that up to 250%, and $185 without federal subsidies match the PMPM memo of 2026-10-01 (p. 1) and §5(1)(b) of the final PY2027 policy (p. 6), which is "Effective for Coverage Beginning January 1, 2027". The 250% limit (§4(1)(c)) and the household cap (§5(1)(d)) are unchanged. Paying $35 at exactly 200% follows the policy's "up to 200% FPL" and the CSR tier edge in 45 CFR 155.305(g)(2). 2026 results are unchanged, the scale's -.inf first threshold is needed and present, and the new ratio variable replaces Washington's inline division instead of adding a copy. Approving.

Optional:

  • Follow-up issue for lawfully present members who lose the federal credit in 2027. The memo (p. 6) says these members "will move to non-federally subsidized group", and its p. 8 exhibit has that group growing from 6,550 to 13,400. In the model a refugee or asylee at about 180% FPL gets $0 in 2027, because Group 3 requires UNDOCUMENTED. It is the same on main and you defer it in the PR body; an issue would keep it tracked (any fix also depends on issue 9553). The documentation at wa_cascade_care_savings_member_amount.py lines 46-49 still says these members "are not separately identifiable in the model", which stops being true in 2027.
  • A wage-driven 2027 pair in integration.yaml. Every 2027 amount case supplies is_aca_ptc_eligible, aca_magi, aca_fpg, slcsp and aca_ptc, and the only 2027 integration scenario sits at 140% FPL, so the $20 band is never reached from real inputs. A single King County adult with wages of $25,000 (ratio 1.566, 12 × 35 = 420) and $35,000 (2.193, 12 × 20 = 240) next to Scenarios 13-14 would cover both bands.
  • Leaner tests. About 12 of the 36 new cases repeat a class another new case pins: member-amount Cases 11, 12, 18 and 19; wa_cascade_care_savings.yaml Cases 27-30 and 35-37; ratio Case 2.
  • Exhibit labels at exactly 200%. The Wakely exhibit in the memo (p. 8) prints "Fed Sub < 200% FPL $35" and "Fed Sub >= 200% FPL $20". The policy text governs, so the value is right; one sentence in the with_federal_subsidy.yaml comment would record the difference.
  • Section number. wa_cascade_care_savings_eligible.py line 33 cites "Section 4(2)" for the filing-behavior exclusions. In the PY2027 policy those are §4(3); §4(2) is now the plan-eligibility subsection.
  • Two assertions. Ratio Case 8 ("not a division by zero") passes with or without the zero-guideline guard. The aca_magi_fraction: 2 and 2.5 outputs run under a 0.01 margin, which is one truncation step; 0.001 would make them bind.

Series-wide (follow-up, not for this PR). wa_cascade_care_savings_fpl_ratio has nothing specific to Washington in it, and the same exact ratio is still inline in aca_ptc_income_eligible and eight other state premium files. One shared guarded variable under gov/aca/eligibility remains the follow-up.

- Member-amount documentation: lawfully present members who lose the
  federal credit in 2027 move to the non-federally subsidized group (memo
  p. 6), but Group 3 requires UNDOCUMENTED, so e.g. a refugee or asylee at
  about 180% FPL gets $0 in 2027 (known limitation, issue 9553).
- Eligibility documentation: cite Section 4(3) of the PY2027 policy for the
  filing-behavior exclusions.
- with_federal_subsidy.yaml: note that the Wakely exhibit (memo p. 8) labels
  the bands "< 200%" and ">= 200%", but the policy text ("up to 200% FPL")
  governs, so exactly 200% gets $35.
- Ratio Case 8 now asserts the member amount (12 * 20 = 240), which an
  unguarded 0 / 0 (NaN, 0) fails; tighten Cases 28 and 34 margins to 0.001
  so the aca_magi_fraction assertions bind.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@DTrim99

DTrim99 commented Nov 20, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Thanks, Ziming. I made four of your optional changes in 32101b0:

  • Documentation: wa_cascade_care_savings_member_amount says the memo (p. 6) moves lawfully present members who lose the federal credit to the non-federally subsidized group, but Group 3 requires UNDOCUMENTED, so a refugee or asylee at about 180% FPL gets $0 in 2027 (issue 9553).
  • Citation: wa_cascade_care_savings_eligible.py now cites §4(3).
  • Exhibit labels: a note in with_federal_subsidy.yaml records the Wakely exhibit's "< 200% / >= 200%" labels and why the policy text governs at exactly 200%.
  • Tests: ratio Case 8 now asserts the member amount (240), which fails with the zero-guideline guard removed. The two cases with aca_magi_fraction 2 and 2.5 use a 0.001 margin.

Not done: the wage-driven integration pair, leaner tests, and the follow-up issue. The Cascade Care tests pass locally (118/118).

@hua7450
hua7450 merged commit 7ab9ad6 into main Nov 20, 2026
40 checks passed
@hua7450
hua7450 deleted the wa-cascade-care-savings-2027 branch November 20, 2026 18:12
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants