Agent Performance Report - Week of 2026-10-25

[github-actions[bot]]

Agent Performance Report - 2026-10-25

Executive Summary

• Window: 24h to 2026-10-25T02:44Z (complete collection, 348 workflows, 145 executed)
• Executed runs: 440, failed: 112 (74.5% success)
• Safe outputs: 309 accepted, 0 rejected (issues 63, discussions 18, PR-related 10 PRs, comments 138)
• Top volume: issue-monster (99 comments, 97% run success), pr-sous-chef (45 outputs), pr-code-quality-reviewer (15), mattpocock-skills-reviewer (13)
• Quality scoring is run/output based only; issue reactions and discussion replies were unavailable (null) in metrics, so no 1-5 content ratings were made this run.

Lowest Executed Success (multi-run workflows)

Workflow	Executed	Failed	Success
ai-moderator	31	29	~6%
design-decision-gate	24	11	54%
test-quality-sentinel	26	11	58%
pr-code-quality-reviewer	29	12	59%
mattpocock-skills-reviewer	27	11	59%
ponytail-reviewer	26	10	62%

These PR-triggered reviewers show correlated failures (also seen on 2026-10-22 with a shared max duration of 9720s), which points to a common infrastructure/timeout cause rather than prompt quality. ponytail-reviewer and mattpocock-skills-reviewer average ~3500s per run, with 0 PRs and only 2-13 comments; they remain redesign-vs-deprecate candidates alongside design-decision-gate.

Patterns

• over-creation (watch): issue-monster 99 comments/day across 34 runs (~3 per run) — acceptable but verify dedup.
• inefficiency: daily-go-test-parallelizer used 13.8M tokens in 10 runs with 0 outputs; avenger 6.7M tokens for 2 issues.
• under-creation: reviewers above spend long runtimes with few outputs.
• Single-run daily workflows with 1/1 failure (about 28) are noted but not scored as systemic.

Recommendations

1. Investigate the shared failure/timeout on the PR reviewer group (ai-moderator, design-decision-gate, test-quality-sentinel, pr-code-quality-reviewer, ponytail/mattpocock reviewers) from run logs before touching prompts.
2. Add output-or-noop self-assessment and success criteria to ponytail and mattpocock reviewers; deprecate if still <60% success next week.
3. Review token budget of daily-go-test-parallelizer (0 outputs, 13.8M tokens).

Notes

Older root causes in shared memory (EACCES #61952, model_not_supported) were not re-verified and are treated as stale. No improvement issues filed: causes unconfirmed from logs this run.

Generated by ⚡ Agent Performance Analyzer - Meta-Orchestrator · copilot · auto · ~20 AIC · ⌖ ~1 AIC · ⊞ 18.5K · ◷

• expires on Oct 26, 2026, 4:54 AM UTC-08:00