diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index 761d6822..edbcd6eb 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -10,6 +10,11 @@ heading here; `tests/test_repo_hygiene.py` asserts that they do. ## [Unreleased] +### OBR page: fiscal rules view and conventions + +- **Fiscal rules on `/obr`.** A new "Against the fiscal rules" section sets the October 2026 EFO path for the current budget (Table 6.5) and public sector net financial liabilities (derived from Table 6.14) beside what the model books for the four worked examples (`results/demo_shocks.json` at obr-macroeconomic-model `0e44ec8`). Only the spending example moves the public finances; the section says it is not a rule readout. No existing figure changes. +- **Conventions on `/obr/methodology`.** Step 2 gains a table of the OBR conventions the emulator inherits as EFO Table 1.9 input paths, imposes through an opt-in overlay, or does not reproduce. + ### Model re-pin and site review (#278, #279) - **#278: model pins.** OBR `2965e82d` → `0e44ec87` (main after obr-macroeconomic-model #74 and #75), BoE SVAR `c13a9c91` → `c827ab86`, FRB/US `846eeb5c` → `162cfe6a`, US HANK `551a40d3` → `58353e5f`. After a redeploy the hosted tools run these pins. The FRB/US and US HANK compare rows with stored paths re-run identically; the OBR rows were re-run at `0e44ec8`. diff --git a/DESIGN.md b/DESIGN.md index 696ba827..501d8572 100644 --- a/DESIGN.md +++ b/DESIGN.md @@ -742,7 +742,7 @@ row (entry cards or chips): the next tab, `/models#compare`, and `/connect` for | Tab | Layout | Must carry | |---|---|---| -| Overview | lede (one sentence: what it answers) → `#verdict` strip (§4.14) → `#fit` good for / not for → `#answers` "What it returns": worked examples behind a scenario switch, stat tiles + sparkline (home of those figures) → `#pe-bridge` the join as a pipeline, one line, and the page's **one** caveat callout → `section#card` model card, collapsed (§4.13) → chip row. No StepPanel, no "About this step" expanders. | link to `/models#compose`, Validation caveats; every other caveat lives on Validation | +| Overview | lede (one sentence: what it answers) → `#verdict` strip (§4.14) → `#fit` good for / not for → `#answers` "What it returns": worked examples behind a scenario switch, stat tiles + sparkline (home of those figures) → on `/obr` only, `#fiscal-rules`: the EFO path table, the examples table and one sources expander → `#pe-bridge` the join as a pipeline, one line, and the page's **one** caveat callout → `section#card` model card, collapsed (§4.13) → chip row. No StepPanel, no "About this step" expanders. | link to `/models#compose`, Validation caveats; every other caveat lives on Validation | | Methodology | StepPanel, one step per model block; panel = equations (`.meth-eq`) | the model's source paper citation (link to Paper tab) | | Validation | stat row (the headline fit numbers: their home) + trust card (§4.13) → StepPanel of the tests (OBR is the reference) → limits card (`#caveats`, every failure statement in full, as `.limits` groups of `details.expander.limit` rows with a visible `h3` per group; r3) → "On this page" rail ≥ 1100 px | the verdict, every known limit, links to the code that produced each number | | Code | `.scrolly-code` StepPanel: install → run → reproduce; panel = commands | `/connect` for hosted use, repo paths | diff --git a/obr/index.html b/obr/index.html index f6407ef3..32a8322e 100644 --- a/obr/index.html +++ b/obr/index.html @@ -157,6 +157,49 @@

Corporation tax main rate up 5 points

+
+

Against the fiscal rules

+

The October 2026 EFO path for the two rules, beside what the model books for the four examples above. Not a rule test: the examples end in 2027Q4, before the target year.

+ +
+ + + + + + + +
The EFO path, October 2026. 2029-30 is the year the Charter names; the current budget is in deficit in 2028-29, so the reading depends on the year tested
Financial year2026-272027-282028-292029-302030-312031-32
Current budget, £bn (surplus +)−40.6−17.5−7.8+14.5+21.7+20.9
PSNFL, % of GDP (derived)83.383.783.582.681.680.9
PSNFL change, pp of GDP (derived)+1.34+0.39−0.20−0.86−0.98−0.74
+
+ + + + + + + + +
What the model books for each example in its third year (2027, four quarters summed)
ExampleReceiptsCurrent spendingNet borrowingWhat is and is not counted
Spending up £1.25bn a quarterno change+£5.7bn+£5.7bnThe cash cost only; receipts do not respond to the higher GDP
1p on the basic rateno changeno changeno changeThe £6.55bn a year costing is the microsimulation’s input; it enters as lower household income, not as model receipts
Bank Rate up 1 pointno changeno changeno changeDebt interest is an input. Checked on the four-quarter run; the sustained run records no fiscal lines
Corporation tax up 5 pointsno changeno changeno changeThe rate moves the cost of capital; no receipts are booked
+

Not a rule readout Only the spending example moves the public finances in the model, by its cash cost, so it lowers the current budget by £5.7bn in 2027. The hosted obr_shock returns none of these lines, and no run reaches 2029-30.

+
+ The rules and the sourcesCharter wording, table derivations, what is missing +
+
    +
  • Source of the rules: HM Treasury, Charter for Budget Responsibility: autumn 2025 (February 2026), paragraphs 3.6 and 3.7. The Charter calls them the fiscal mandate and a supplementary target; stability rule and investment rule are the names in common use.
  • +
  • Target year: 2029-30, until 2029-30 becomes the third year of the forecast period; after that, the third year of the rolling forecast. The Charter text does not say which applies to an October 2026 forecast, so the table shows every year.
  • +
  • Current budget: the “Current budget deficit” row of Table 6.5 with the sign reversed, from the October 2026 EFO aggregates workbook in the model repository.
  • +
  • PSNFL: not printed in the committed workbooks. Derived from Table 6.14 as minus (net worth less non-financial assets less unfunded pension liabilities). This is our subtraction, in percentage points of GDP only; no £bn headroom is given.
  • +
  • Examples: the PSCR (receipts), PSCE (current spending) and PSNBNSA (net borrowing) changes in results/demo_shocks.json, rows cgg, household_costing, bank_rate and corporation_tax_rate. The current budget is receipts less current spending less depreciation.
  • +
  • Missing: the OBR’s own headroom figures, a model run to 2029-30 that records the current budget, and any response of receipts or debt interest to the economy (limits).
  • +
+
+
+
+

How far to trust it

Three checks, weakest included; each opens its evidence.

diff --git a/obr/methodology/index.html b/obr/methodology/index.html index ec64c456..48c0d43b 100644 --- a/obr/methodology/index.html +++ b/obr/methodology/index.html @@ -160,6 +160,38 @@

Why it matters

The snapshot ships inside the package, so there is no download step. It gives the circular fiscal and financial sub-blocks real balancing data rather than guessed starting values.

+ +
+ OBR conventions: inherited, opt-in or absentMarket paths, oil and gas, sterling, multipliers, judgement +
+

A convention is a rule the OBR applies outside its equations, such as taking interest rates from financial markets. The emulator handles each in one of three ways.

+
    +
  • Inherited: read as a fixed input path from the EFO’s Table 1.9, “Market-derived assumptions”. The emulator applies no rule of its own.
  • +
  • Opt-in overlay: imposed by a labelled switch on the model’s run_reform, off by default.
  • +
  • Absent: not reproduced, or loaded but used by no equation.
  • +
+
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
OBR conventions and the emulator, October 2026 EFO, model pin 0e44ec8
ConventionIn the emulatorStatus
Bank Rate and gilt yields from market curvesTable 1.9 paths for Bank Rate (R) and the 20-year gilt yield (RL). No curve is built, and neither responds to a fiscal shockinherited
Mortgage and deposit ratesTable 1.9 paths (RMORT, RDEP). monetary_conditioning moves the mortgage rate with Bank Rate (Bank Rate limits); the deposit rate, gilt yields, sterling and house prices stay fixedinherited opt-in overlay
Oil price from futuresTable 1.9 path (PBRENT). Its note: Brent spot for outturn, ICE Brent futures over the forecast windowinherited
Gas price from futuresTable 1.9 path, loaded as PGAS but used by no equation in the listing, so it has no effect. Its note: one-month-forward gas price expectations averaged over the forecast windowabsent
Exchange rate held flatTable 1.9 path (RX): the sterling index is constant at 85.7 from 2026Q4 to 2032Q1. Sterling moves trade prices only, never volumesinherited
Fiscal multipliers imposed by judgement, fading to zero over five yearspublished_conventions imposes the OBR’s impact multipliers on government consumption and investment (multiplier, capital spending). The straight-line fade between the two published points is our choiceopt-in overlay
Indirect taxes passed through to pricesprice_passthrough, for VAT and fuel duty shocks (VAT limits)opt-in overlay
Multiplier fade dated from the announcementThe fade starts at the shock start; the emulator has no announcement dateabsent
Quarter-by-quarter forecast judgementRecent add-factors are averaged and held flat (limits)absent
Fresh market data between EFOsThe paths are those of the pinned EFO; no curve date or averaging window is applied or updatedabsent
+ +