diff --git a/data/specifications/gbfs.md b/data/specifications/gbfs.md index cd44ae0..0d08ba1 100644 --- a/data/specifications/gbfs.md +++ b/data/specifications/gbfs.md @@ -12,29 +12,29 @@ adoption: lifecycle: active tier: hundred_plus adopters_count: 1536 - adopters_count_updated: '2026-11-04' + adopters_count_updated: '2026-11-10' adopters_registry_url: https://mobilitydatabase.org/feeds?gbfs=true confirmed_by_maintainer: true principles: cost_restriction_free: verdict: compliant - rationale: 'Yes' - evidence_url: https://gbfs.org/documentation/faq/ + rationale: 'CC BY 3.0: "You are free to share, copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format for any purpose, even commercially"' + evidence_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0 publicly_documented: verdict: compliant - rationale: 'Yes' + rationale: 'The full documentation is available publicly' evidence_url: https://gbfs.org/documentation/reference/ independent_maintainer: verdict: compliant - rationale: 'Yes' - evidence_url: https://gbfs.org/documentation/process/ + rationale: 'Actively maintained by MobilityData, an international non-profit organization. The maintainer facilitates specification development between data producers and data consumers and does not unilaterally decide its content.' + evidence_url: https://mobilitydata.org/governance structured_releases: verdict: compliant rationale: 'Yes' evidence_url: https://github.com/MobilityData/gbfs/releases open_governance: verdict: compliant - rationale: 'Yes' + rationale: 'GBFS is developed and maintained by the community of producers and consumers of GBFS data. Anyone can propose a change and vote.' evidence_url: https://gbfs.org/documentation/process/ --- diff --git a/data/specifications/gofs.md b/data/specifications/gofs.md index 6a2abb7..bd100d3 100644 --- a/data/specifications/gofs.md +++ b/data/specifications/gofs.md @@ -16,16 +16,16 @@ adoption: principles: cost_restriction_free: verdict: compliant - rationale: Yes, Apache 2.0 - evidence_url: https://github.com/MobilityData/GOFS + rationale: GOFS is free to use. Apache 2.0 allows commercial use. + evidence_url: https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0.txt publicly_documented: verdict: compliant rationale: Yes Specification, JSON schema, and governance process are all published in full on GitHub evidence_url: https://github.com/MobilityData/GOFS/blob/main/reference.md independent_maintainer: verdict: compliant - rationale: Yes MobilityData is an independent nonprofit; the Maintainer role facilitates but does not vote on changes. - evidence_url: https://mobilitydata.org/history/ + rationale: 'Actively maintained by MobilityData, an international non-profit organization. The maintainer facilitates specification development between data producers and data consumers and does not unilaterally decide its content.' + evidence_url: https://mobilitydata.org/governance structured_releases: verdict: compliant rationale: Yes Structured MAJOR/MINOR release cycle with changelog via GitHub releases. diff --git a/data/specifications/gtfs-flex.md b/data/specifications/gtfs-flex.md index fd8254b..2fc41a8 100644 --- a/data/specifications/gtfs-flex.md +++ b/data/specifications/gtfs-flex.md @@ -12,32 +12,32 @@ licences: scopes: [documentation] first_release_year: 2020 adoption: - lifecycle: early_adoption - tier: early + lifecycle: active + tier: hundred_plus + adopters_count: 126 + adopters_count_updated: '2026-11-10' + adopters_registry_url: https://mobilitydatabase.org/feeds?features=Booking+Rules%2CFixed-Stops+Demand+Responsive+Transit%2CPredefined+Routes+with+Deviation%2CZone-Based+Demand+Responsive+Services&official=true confirmed_by_maintainer: true principles: cost_restriction_free: verdict: compliant - rationale: Apache 2.0 - evidence_url: https://github.com/google/transit?tab=Apache-2.0-1-ov-file + rationale: GTFS Flex is free to use. Apache 2.0 allows commercial use. + evidence_url: https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0.txt publicly_documented: verdict: compliant - rationale: Apache 2.0 - evidence_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ + rationale: The full documentation is available publicly. + evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/getting-started/features/flexible-services independent_maintainer: verdict: compliant - rationale: |- - Official Maintainer: MobilityData. - - (GitHub repo still held by Google. Google delegated admin rights to MobilityData.) - evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/community/governance/gtfs-schedule-governance/roles/ + rationale: 'Actively maintained by MobilityData, an international non-profit organization. The maintainer facilitates specification development between data producers and data consumers and does not unilaterally decide its content.' + evidence_url: https://mobilitydata.org/governance structured_releases: verdict: compliant - rationale: Changelog + rationale: Change history available evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/documentation/schedule/change-history/revision-history/ open_governance: verdict: compliant - rationale: Anyone can vote with equal rights. + rationale: Anyone can become a Contributor by participating in discussions within the official GTFS repository, regardless of their technical skills or experience with GTFS. Everyone can vote with equal rights. evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/community/governance/gtfs-schedule-governance/roles/ --- diff --git a/data/specifications/gtfs-realtime.md b/data/specifications/gtfs-realtime.md index 0d337a6..9fe9dee 100644 --- a/data/specifications/gtfs-realtime.md +++ b/data/specifications/gtfs-realtime.md @@ -14,36 +14,30 @@ first_release_year: 2011 adoption: lifecycle: active tier: hundred_plus - adopters_count: 632 - adopters_count_updated: '2026-09-29' + adopters_count: 666 + adopters_count_updated: '2026-11-10' adopters_registry_url: https://mobilitydatabase.org/feeds?gtfs_rt=true confirmed_by_maintainer: true principles: cost_restriction_free: verdict: compliant - rationale: Apache 2.0 - evidence_url: https://github.com/google/transit?tab=Apache-2.0-1-ov-file + rationale: GTFS is free to use. Apache 2.0 allows commercial use. + evidence_url: https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0.txt publicly_documented: verdict: compliant - rationale: CC-BY-3.0 - evidence_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ + rationale: The full documentation is available publicly. + evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/documentation/overview independent_maintainer: verdict: compliant - rationale: |- - Defacto Steward: MobilityData. - - (GitHub repo still held by Google. Google delegated admin rights to MobilityData.) - evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/community/governance/gtfs-realtime-amendment-process/ + rationale: 'Actively maintained by MobilityData, an international non-profit organization. The maintainer facilitates specification development between data producers and data consumers and does not unilaterally decide its content.' + evidence_url: https://mobilitydata.org/governance structured_releases: verdict: compliant - rationale: Changelog + rationale: Change history available evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/documentation/realtime/change-history/revision-history/ open_governance: verdict: compliant - rationale: |- - Anyone can vote with equal rights. - - Note: Interface between governance and actual protobuf file implementation + rationale: Anyone can become a Contributor by participating in discussions within the official GTFS repository, regardless of their technical skills or experience with GTFS. Everyone can vote with equal rights. evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/community/governance/gtfs-realtime-amendment-process/ --- diff --git a/data/specifications/gtfs-schedule.md b/data/specifications/gtfs-schedule.md index 5b0d95d..4ede629 100644 --- a/data/specifications/gtfs-schedule.md +++ b/data/specifications/gtfs-schedule.md @@ -14,33 +14,30 @@ first_release_year: 2006 adoption: lifecycle: active tier: hundred_plus - adopters_count: 2950 - adopters_count_updated: '2026-09-29' + adopters_count: 3010 + adopters_count_updated: '2026-11-10' adopters_registry_url: https://mobilitydatabase.org/feeds?gtfs=true confirmed_by_maintainer: true principles: cost_restriction_free: verdict: compliant - rationale: Apache 2.0 - evidence_url: https://github.com/google/transit?tab=Apache-2.0-1-ov-file + rationale: GTFS Flex is free to use. Apache 2.0 allows commercial use. + evidence_url: https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0.txt publicly_documented: verdict: compliant - rationale: Apache 2.0 - evidence_url: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ + rationale: The full documentation is available publicly. + evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/documentation/overview independent_maintainer: verdict: compliant - rationale: |- - Official Maintainer: MobilityData. - - (GitHub repo still held by Google. Google delegated admin rights to MobilityData.) - evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/community/governance/gtfs-schedule-governance/roles/ + rationale: 'Actively maintained by MobilityData, an international non-profit organization. The maintainer facilitates specification development between data producers and data consumers and does not unilaterally decide its content.' + evidence_url: https://mobilitydata.org/governance structured_releases: verdict: compliant - rationale: Changelog + rationale: Change history available evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/documentation/schedule/change-history/revision-history/ open_governance: verdict: compliant - rationale: Anyone can vote with equal rights. + rationale: Anyone can become a Contributor by participating in discussions within the official GTFS repository, regardless of their technical skills or experience with GTFS. Everyone can vote with equal rights. evidence_url: https://gtfs.org/community/governance/gtfs-schedule-governance/roles/ ---